The Global Development Gateway and the Central Dilemma of E-Commerce

The criticisms that have been raised of the GDG have mainly been of "crowding out" (of existing sites), skewed funding priorities (toward WB associated sites rather than indigenous or grass-roots developed sites), and supposed self-dealing (of WB officials). I won't go into those--they have been well presented by others and particularly on the GKD listserve. What interests me is how the strengths and weaknesses of the site(s) are so revealing of larger issues concerning Development and the very harsh realities that are being discovered about information and E-Commerce on the Net.