As poverty soars, how reliable is the World Bank, IMF development policy?
The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF), major backers of economic reforms in developing countries, have once again unveiled a new poverty reduction approach which they claim gives borrowing countries an opportunity to determine their own strategies. However, critics have been quick to dismiss it as just one of the many faces of the Bretton Woods institutions, which have repeatedly failed to answer development needs of the world's poorest countries ever since they came into being more than half a century ago.
Southern African Research and Documentation Centre
(SARDC) - Harare - 01/June/2000 - Grace Buhera
The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund
(IMF), major backers of economic reforms in developing
countries, have once again unveiled a new poverty
reduction approach which they claim gives borrowing
countries an opportunity to determine their own
strategies. However, critics have been quick to
dismiss it as just one of the many faces of the
Bretton Woods institutions, which have repeatedly
failed to answer development needs of the world's
poorest countries ever since they came into being more
than half a century ago.
Historically, development policies of the West towards
the Less Developed Countries (LDCs) have usually led
to a vicious circle of vulnerability and crisis,
including reactive aid, which has not benefited the
intended countries. Six countries from the Southern
African Development Community (SADC) region - Lesotho,
Malawi, Mozambique, Tanzania, Zambia and Zimbabwe -
have adopted structural adjustment policies (SAPs) on
the recommendations of - and under pressure from - the
IMF.
Generally, the enforcement of the IMF prescription has
not achieved the desired results. Most countries, with
the exception of Mozambique, are still grappling with
under-achieving economies - high inflation, serious
budget deficits and low gross domestic product (GDP).
It is interesting to note, however, that Mozambique is
one of the few African countries that has qualified
for aid under the Highly Indebted Poor Countries
(HIPC). Recent catastrophic floods earlier this year
will undoubtedly also constrain the country's growth.
Recognising the limited effectiveness of their SAP
reform strategies, the IMF and the World Bank recently
introduced initiatives "to mitigate costs, create
social safety nets, improve the composition of public
expenditures and the equity aspects of economic
policies," a recent World Bank report says.
The September 1999 annual board meetings of the IMF
and the World Bank came up with a mandate to integrate
objectives of poverty reduction and growth more fully
into the institutions' operations in 75 poor
countries. A new facility was the result, the Poverty
Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF) or the New
Washington Consensus, in the language of the two
institutions. The change in policy direction by the
Bank and the Fund to PRGF is perhaps recognition of
the complementarity of macroeconomic, structural and
social policies. It can also be interpreted as
reflecting the realisation that a comprehensive policy
approach is needed to make consistent and broad-based
inroads into poverty reduction in developing
countries.
Under this new policy thrust, documents called Poverty
Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs) will be prepared
locally by government representatives, with active
participation of civil society, NGOs, donors and
international institutions.
The Bank is currently training country teams,
comprising government officials and the civil society.
The exercise was launched at a seminar in Abidjan,
Ivory Coast, in March.
Locally produced PRSPs, the Bank and the Fund say,
will help countries own reform programmes, which may
encourage them to be more committed to the process.
This "consultative process" has already begun in many
African countries including Tanzania, although it is
still too early to measure the degree of its success.
Read the full analysis from:
http://www.misanet.com/development2.html