WRI: Environmental Decentralisation Promotes Democracy
The World Resources Institute (WRI) urged African countries today to strategically decentralise control over its natural resources as a means of strengthening democracy and protecting the environment.
Careful decentralisation of power over environment
promotes democracy, development in Africa
from the World Resources Institute
March26 , 2001
Cape town - The World Resources Institute (WRI) urged
African countries today to strategically decentralise
control over its natural resources as a means of
strengthening democracy and protecting the
environment.
"Decentralisation in Africa is very promising but as
it is currently implemented, it will not encourage
democracy, or deliver greater efficiency, equity and
environmental protection," warned Jesse Ribot of the
World Resources Institute (WRI).
The WRI researcher was in Cape town today addressing a
United Nations meeting on decentralising local
governance in Africa. Development agencies,
non-governmental organisations, and governments in
Africa are promoting greater participation by local
people in the use, maintenance and restoration of
their natural resources.
Already, some African countries are decentralising or
transferring environmental management responsibilities
and powers from the central government to local
bodies.
"Unfortunately, in many African countries,
decentralisation merely means the transfer of powers
to centrally controlled, non-democratic, unaccountable
local institutions," said Ribot.
These local groups include traditional chiefs,
religious orders, non-governmental organisations or
business groups. He cited cases in Mali and Uganda
wherein many forests, which were previously in the
public domain, are being privatised in the name of
decentralisation.
Cases also exist in Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Guinea,
Malawi and Zimbabwe where only local power elites -
not the general population - have benefited. Tundu
Lissu, staff attorney of Lawyers' Environmental Action
Team (LEAT) in Tanzania agrees with this assessment.
He said that in most cases, the centralised state -
characterised by authoritarianism and the lack of
political space for popular democracy - has been
replicated at the local levels.
"The result has been called decentralised despotism -
an even more oppressive and unaccountable local
governance structure at local levels."
Lissu adds that careful decentralisation is crucial
since whoever controls local decision-making
ultimately controls local resources, which is the key
to rural development in Africa.
"Decentralising powers over natural resources without
ensuring that local groups are accountable to the
community at large or represent the general population
is dangerous," said Ribot.
"Giving public powers to un-democratic authorities
slows down democratic transitions."
The WRI's Ribot recommends the following:
establishment of democratic local governments to
ensure greater public participation in local decisions
concerning decentralisation of natural resources. For
example, Mali and Senegal changed their laws to allow
independent candidates in local elections, helping to
make local governments more accountable
encourage transparency and accountability of all local
authorities who are engaged in the management of local
resources. This has also been recommended by Alois
Mandondo of the University of Zimbabwe's Institute of
Environmental Studies
transfer to accountable local authorities significant
powers over public natural resources and powers of
value to local people
make certain that the legal instruments used to
establish local accountability and to transfer powers
are secure so that transfers are made as rights rather
than as privileges to be given and taken back by
central authorities
"Decentralization of control over local natural
resources has only began in Africa," said Ribot. "This
is the right path but one that should be tread
carefully."