Shell is haunted by its record in Ogoni

One of the most controversial clashes of the 1990s between local communities, government and multinationals occurred in the oil rich Ogoni area on the Niger delta. The oil operator, Royal Dutch Shell, withdrew from the area in 1993 but for several years faced unrelenting criticism of its standards and relationship with the Nigerian government of General Sani Abacha. By 1998 Shell was claiming to have embarked upon a fundamental rethink of its corporate priorities and followed this claim up with a massive public relations blitzkrieg which has achieved a great deal in how the company is perceived.

Shell now faces its Annual General Meeting, followed by an international environment award, claiming that it is a reformed company which has become the champion of human rights and the environment. Such extravagant claims were always likely to face challenges and this week MOSOP and Friends of the Earth seem set to present separate challenges to Shell's 'born again' environmental status.

One of the most serious problems Shell faces is the question of whether it has actually achieved any meaningful reform of its practices in Nigeria. MOSOP (Movement of the Ogoni People) activists would argue that little has changed, challenging Shell on a number of occasions over the company's response over the last two weeks to a major oil blowout at an abandoned well in eastern Ogoni.

The latest incident comes just as Shell is taking on a new chairman and facing up to shareholders on Thursday. John Watts, the incoming chair, has already committed the company to a policy of not returning to operations in Ogoni till all parties are agreed. To make its claims about reform credible Shell needs to do more. It needs to show that it is capable of moving past the tense standoff which has existed between its subsidiary SPDC and the Ogoni people over the last two years of civilian rule.

MOSOP is now arguing that Shell can start to show that it has changed by making good on its promises to clean up the environment in Ogoni, starting with this latest major oil spill. Shell this week, as it has for several years, claimed that it is ready to 'clean up oil spills which occurred since it left in 1993', conveniently making no mention of spills occurring before 1993. Ogoni and other communities have compared past 'cleanups' by Shell to 'cover up' operations so one immediate question is whether Shell is able to show that this time it is willing to be unambiguous about its intentions and show that its international standards apply in Nigeria.

It is also time for Royal Dutch Shell to face up to questions over its failure to resolve the company's dispute with the Ogoni people. Is, as Shell claims, the sole barrier to progress the difficulties in dialogue with the local population or has Shell failed to win the confidence of the local people?

The most often cited comment from Nigeria correspondents is a lack of trust between the local people and Shell. Ogoni is not the only community that is deeply suspicious of Shell. The gap between its claims of progress in relations with communities and independent reporting is becoming increasingly worrying. Perhaps it is time for Shell to commit unambiguously to allowing qualified third parties to come in to examine and report upon disputes which are clearly harming the local people, Shell's reputation, and the people of the Niger delta.
Ledum Mitee (MOSOP)

Movement for the survival of the Ogoni people (MOSOP)

MOSOP contacts in Nigeria
27 Odu Street, Ogbunabari, Port Harcourt
Rivers State, Nigeria
(234) 84 233 907 ph/fax (NOTE NEW !!)
mosop@phca.linkserve.com
mosop99@mosop.org

Internatiional office
MOSOP International Secretariat
Suite 4, 1 Mermaid Court, Borough High Street
London SE1 1HR, United Kingdom
ph(+44)2073570304
Fax (+44)2073570305
mosop@gn.apc.org