In Defence of Porto Alegre
It was with great dismay that we read over Mihai Zamfir’s recent article “Forum” in last week’s issue of Romania literara. Zamfir puts himself forward as a ‘neutral’ observer, seeking to weigh the positive and negative aspects of the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, and the World Social Forum in Porto Alegre, Brazil, coming out in favour of the former. His dismissal of those who gathered in Porto Alegre is based upon their predisposition to violence and irrationality, and their failure to come up with a final document or communique (clearly untrue in light of the final communique which came out of Porto Alegre, translated into three languages--English, Spanish, and Portuguese--and signed by more than 170 organisations from around the world).