COMIC RELIEF CAPITULATES TO RIGHT WING PRESSURES

One of the first decisions that George W Bush took when he reached the White House was to announce that the US aid programme would not fund family planning programmes with any element of abortion. Now one of the best known fundraising operations in the UK - which has raised 115 million of pounds for development programmes carried out by British NGOs in Africa - has capitulated to pressures from the right-wing lobby and the Catholic Church.

Apparently desperate to get money at any cost, Comic Relief has set up a separate bank account for funds that will not be used for projects working on sexual and reproductive health.

In its defence, Comic Relief said less than 3% of all funds spent has been allocated to projects with a family planning component.In a continent ravaged by HIV and AIDS, this statistic is shocking enough, casting doubt on the extent to which Comic Relief's funds are being used to meet Africa's priorities. Any serious analysis of poverty and its solutions will conclude that the involvement of women in the development process is fundamental. Their involvement, their health and that of their children, is intimately linked to their ability to make choices, including their ability to make informed decisions about family size.

For Comic Relief to bow to the pressures of the right effectively reduces the already small amount it devotes to work on sexual and reproductive health in Africa. It sets a precedent for other rightwing pressure groups to ask for their donations to be ring-fenced. What will Comic Relief say when that lobby says it wants none of its money to be used to help blacks?

Many NGOs in the UK have circulated protest letters to Comic Relief. Such protests come in the wake of growing criticism of the way in which Africans are portrayed in television programmes produced by Comic Relief for its fund-raising work. Many believe that these programmes portray African people merely as passive recipients of white benefactors instead of as people who fight against poverty, exploitation and injustice.