• Contributor | Governance

    I would be very interested to learn what any of you think of the recent book by Hernando de Soto: The Mystery of Capital. Does it shed some light on why, in spite of transfers of "the $56 billion that OECD countries counted as Official Development Assistance (ODA) in 1999", and much larger sums over the last 50 years, "it is equally obvious that ... poverty and inequality continuing to increase".

    If the 20th century model of development is not working, clearly we need to find a 21st century approach that delivers more positive results.

    de Soto writes about capitalism flourishing in a bell jar. What is the bell jar made of? If it is made of transparent laws, financial institutions, regulatory regimes & culture in some dynamic mix, then "expanding the jar" is what de Soto is talking about. The point is that all peoples have to have a seat at the table and a voice in the conversation as full partners. This is clearly not the case today. It was obvious to me in rural Jamaica that the control of the flows of information and money were widely seen as the keys to political power. It is reasonably obvious that this view of power is also currently dominant in Washington, D.C. as well. Attempts to free these flows from centralized controls of the elites is generally seen as subversive and most unwelcome.

    US political theory at its best assumes that we, the people, are all full partners in our self government. In too many cases, however, citizens and consumers are NOT seen as partners. Too often we the people are viewed merely as passive targets to be manipulated and controlled by monologues and advertising from the elites in the center, be they left wing communists or right wing capitalists.

    One thing I am guessing is that neither de Soto nor the KABISSA-FAHAMU NEWSLETTER discuss, or fully value, the power of the Internet to give many more citizens a seat at the table and a voice in the conversation as full partners. What's more, the Internet grants these new partners powers which are greatly amplified by the possibilities of self organizing collective actions at the local level of the edge. The Internet is, after all, fundamentally about exchange and conversation at the edge, independent of the center.

    It just may be that the online gaming experience will catalyze self organizing political action groups. That is, gaming may have the unexpected and unintended consequences of allowing very large numbers of people to experience the power of collaborative actions and communications which they control as partners.

    Thoughts?

    – jock gill

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    In July the World Bank will launch a multi- million dollar internet-based development knowledge initiative at . Trumpeted as a place to find diverse perspectives on development, the Bank argues that its Development Gateway will be a convenient tool for civil society groups, officials, journalists and independent researchers. We disagree. On closer scrutiny, the Development Gateway initiative looks less like an attempt to encourage debate than a means to stifle, moderate and control dissenting opinion. We wish to warn colleagues of the perils of associating with or supporting this project.

    There are three fundamental objections to the Gateway project. First the gateway privileges certain voices over others. The Gateway does not prioritise poorer people as site contributors, editors or viewers. The Bank's heavy English-language bias exacerbates the dominance of official 'development knowledge'. You will not find topics on "political economy" or "inequality" or "discrimination", just concepts like "governance" and "human development". Moreover the Gateway's 130-issue taxonomy ghettoises cross-cutting issues such as gender and climate change.

    Second, the claim that the site is independent is untenable. This is a clear attempt by the Bank to consolidate itself and its allies as the main authorities on "development knowledge". This is reflected in both the content and process of the Gateway. For instance, in order to provide local content, the Gateway has its own country portals. These will be run by government officials, private business and civil society groups appointed without any clear criteria of representativeness. The content of these gateways will be policed. Within these country gateways, site contributors are told to avoid "country/locale specific events", and not to use metaphors, puns or irony in order "to aid machine translation".

    The Bank is appointing individual or institutional "topic guides" to filter and organise material in each of the site's subject areas. The Gateway is supposed to represent all perspectives and all types of analysis. The only reason to exclude items is if they fail to meet the site's "quality" criteria, yet it remains extremely unclear as to how this quality threshold is determined. And given the volume and diversity of information posted on the internet daily, it is unlikely that the guides' coverage will be comprehensive. With the best will in the world, then, topic guides' selections will be biased in favour of the intellectual tastes of themselves and their contacts.

    The third, and most pernicious, effect of the development gateway is to undermine alternatives. Instead of encouraging existing initiatives, the Bank has chosen to centralise internet coverage of development issues in a bid to sift and control the flow of ideas. This is likely to distract from and damage the development of diverse, independent internet sites on these issues.

    This is why, in our individual capacities, we pledge to avoid all contact, whether official or otherwise, with the World Bank's Development Gateway. We encourage our colleagues to undertake a similar pledge, and to support alternative sources of knowledge.

    Signed (as individuals, organisation names provided for reference only)

    Initial signatories:

    Yash Tandon, International South Group Network, Zimbabwe
    Patrick Bond, University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa
    Phil McMichael, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY
    Chris Brooke, Magdalen College, Oxford University
    Rutendo Kambarami, Communications Officer, Mwelekeo waNGO, Zimbabwe

    To sign, send a message to gateway@voiceoftheturtle.org with your name and organization in the subject line.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    Publications Series on African Union

    After decades of debate, posturing and grappling, the African Union is here. But what is the background to this historic juncture in the continent's history? Who has played a role, and what are the different positions in the debate?Significantly, what are the implications and challenges for the future? This series on African Union produced by the Africa Institute of South Africa answers these questions and many more. If you're concerned about Africa's future, can you afford to be without them? Volumes in the Series:

    A United States of Africa?
    Edited by Eddy Maloka
    June 2001. 476 pp. Paperback. ISBN 0 7983 0146 5. R120.00 or US $30.00

    Towards an African Economic Community
    By SKB Asante, FOC Nwonwu and VN Muzvidziwa
    June 2001. 64 pp. Paperback. ISBN 0 7983 0147 3. R25.00 or US $10.00

    Africa in the new Millennium: Challenges and Prospects
    Edited by Eddy Maloka and Elizabeth le Roux
    June 2001. 144 pp. Paperback. ISBN 0 7983 0145 7. R60.00 or US $15.00

    African Foreign Policies in the 21st Century: Working Papers
    By Luis Serapião, Sehlare Makgetlaneng, VS Sheth, Francis Makoa, Moses
    Ralinala, Christopher Saudners and Wilfred Ndongko
    March 2001. 78 pp. Paperback. ISBN 0 7983 0142 2. R40.00 or US $10.00

    African Union and a Pan-African Parliament: Working Papers
    Manelisi Genge, Francis Kornegay and Stephen Rule
    October 2000. 40 pp. Paperback. ISBN 0 7983 0140 6. R25.00 or US $10.00.

    Order these publications directly from the Africa Institute: PO Box 630, Pretoria 0001, South Africa
    Tel: +27 12 328 6970 Fax: +27 12 323 8153 Email: [email]ai@ai.org.za or [email]beth@ai.org.za

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    Pan African Institute for Development - West Africa (PAID-WA)

    PAID-WA has been running the IRD course for 32 years, during which the course has attracted 1421 students from 23 nationalities.
    This is a multi-disciplinary program that runs for one academic year to prepare participants for an integrated approach to development. Its main focus is to equip participants with the skills needed to identify and handle development problems more effectively in rural and urban communities. On completion, a diploma in Integrated Rural Development (IRD) is awarded.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    First we would like to thank all of you who responded to our survey questionnaire. We received a 5% return (308 replies). The distribution of our respondents did not reflect our subscriber base, with a disproportionately lower number of responses returned from African countries. The results are nevertheless interesting.

    · 55% of respondents work in Africa
    · 39% work in NGOs, 13% in Universities, 10% in international agencies, and the remainder in sectors such as consultancies, media, private sector, CBOs, government, and funding agencies
    · We asked which three categories of the newsletter were you liked most:
    o Rights and democracy 37%
    o Development 33%
    o Conflict, emergencies and crises 25%
    o Education and social welfare 25%
    o Editorial 27%
    o Health 21%
    o Women and gender 20%
    o Internet and technology 19%

    We suspect that these findings indicate that in many areas we may need to improve the quality of materials that we include. We hope we can do so with your help. Please continue to send us information for inclusion in the newsletter.

    As you know, we will be closing down during August, and during that time we hope to be able to make some changes to the structure of the newsletter to make it easier for you to use the materials we publish.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    Small World Theatre (SWT) collaborated with Tanzanian performers to find out what prevents people, particularly women in poor communities, from participating in elections.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    The World Bank signalled yesterday its strong determination to weed out corrupt practices among firms bidding for its lucrative contracts. Commenting in the wake of a high-profile corruption case in Lesotho, Happy Nkhoma, the bank's spokesman in SA, said the bank would black list companies that were found guilty of corruption in the trial.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    DaimlerChrysler, the German car manufacturer, tried to distance itself yesterday from a policy of supplying discounted cars to senior South African government officials by a subsidiary company participating in a R43bn (Pounds 3.8bn) defence deal.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    The World Bank Group is preparing a Private Sector Development Strategy to be presented to its Executive Directors in December 2001. The task for the Strategy is to set out how developing country governments, through sound policy and institutions, can best tap and promote private initiative to pursue socially useful goals. A paper setting out the major themes to be covered in the Strategy is now available for discussion and comment.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    The recent results of the annual Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) by Transparency International are no good news for anti-corruption campaigners in Zimbabwe.

    Tagged under Governance Zimbabwe

  • Contributor | Governance

    Comradeship within government could result in more "irregularities", like the R43bn arms deal being swept under the carpet, PAC MP Patricia de Lille said here on Sunday.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    PRESIDENT Abdoulaye Wade of Senegal, speaking on the eve of the birth of a new African Union, said that the continent is poised to make a "political leap forward" as Europe has done. Wade, speaking here ahead of the last-ever summit of the Organisation of African Unity (OAU) on Monday through Wednesday, warned against gradual integration and urged that African development follow a joint strategy instead of each country fending for itself.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    To be held 23-24 August 2001, at the Ridgeway Hotel, Johannesburg, in conjunction with the DSSA Bi-Annual Conference.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    The Prime Minister of Tanzania, Frederick Sumaye, has said that tough pre-conditions were making it difficult for Tanzania to take advantage of debt relief under the Highly Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) initiative, the 'Guardian' newspaper reported on Tuesday.

    Tagged under Governance Tanzania

  • Contributor | Governance

    The Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions (ZCTU) was in a quandary after its two-day stayaway on Wednesday, over its next move to force the government to scrap sharp fuel price increases. At the same time, its leadership faced pressure from its members to plan indefinite mass action, including demonstrations against President Robert Mugabe, the 'Financial Gazette' has reported.

    Tagged under Governance Zimbabwe

  • Contributor | Governance

    Livestock exports have resumed in earnest in Somalia, after a ban by the Gulf states brought the trade to a halt. The ban was imposed in September 2000 on the Horn of Africa after an outbreak of Rift Valley fever (RVF) in Saudi Arabia and Yemen - the first recorded epidemic outside Africa. Coming on the heels of a three-year regional drought, the ban hit pastoralist communities hard, particularly in areas of Ethiopia and northern Somalia.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    The United Nations Security Council has extended the mandate of the Mission for the Referendum in Western Sahara (MINURSO) by five months to 30 November. The decision was based on the UN Secretary-General's report on the situation in the disputed territory. The report includes a draft framework agreement prepared by James Baker III, the Special Envoy of the Secretary-General to Western Sahara.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    OH, THE shame. As usual, African countries have scored dismally in Transparency International's latest global corruption index. But hold on a minute. The rankings bring to mind the (true) story of an African businessman who swallows his cellphone microchip in desperation as police close in to arrest him for corruption involving top government officials. Such a scene is not difficult to imagine in corruption-riddled Africa, is it? Except that this incident took place not in Africa, but in France.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    PRESIDENT Robert Mugabe’s government has arbitrarily increased by 2000 the number of white-owned commercial farms targeted for confiscation under the fast-track land resettlement programme, further jeopardising the country’s food security, it was established this week.

    Tagged under Governance Zimbabwe

  • Contributor | Governance

    The demand for 100% cancellation of Third World debt is being advanced by progressive civil society groups like Jubilee South and the Zimbabwe Coalition on Debt and Development (Zimcodd). Zimbabwe is officially considered only “moderately” indebted by the World Bank. Yet the burden of repayment is so brutal that government finally said no to foreign debt repayment around a year ago, and drove the interest rate down to at least 45% below inflation earlier this year so as to lower domestic debt repayment.

    Tagged under Governance Zimbabwe