New on-line publication: Human Rights and Social Development: Toward
Democratization and Social Justice / Democracy, Governance and Human Rights
Programme Paper Number 5 - October 2001 / United Nations Research Institute for Social Development (UNRISD).Tagged under GovernanceBacked by the Infrastructure and Urban Development Department (IUDD) of the UK
Department for International Development (DFID) id21Urban Poverty offers a searchable database of concise, easy-to-read summaries of development research on urban themes.Tagged under GovernanceA newly published CD Rom “Youth Actions for Sustainable Local Development in Senegal: From Global to Local Agendas” is the result of a research initiative undertaken within the framework of the International Year of Volunteers 2001 and aiming to gather information on all aspects related to youth volunteering and participation in Senegal. “Capitalizing 10 years in volunteering actions, I wish to share with all of you this important tool for research, training, learning experiences conducted abroad, advocacy and lobbying.” - Ibrahima Kane, Founder and President of the Senegalese Youth and Human Settlements Development Network, Senegal.
Tagged under Governance SenegalI have recently returned from South Africa where I have been helping with the launch of the Artists for Human Rights "Break the Silence" HIV/AIDS Billboard and Print Portfolio Project at Durban City Art Gallery and the National Gallery of Art in Cape Town. Whilst the billboards, with the help of Corporate sponsorship, are slowly but surely finding their way out into the communities of South Africa, the print portfolio will tour next year to a variety of countries and locations highlighting the need for a global effort to help those who are suffering from the HIV/AIDS pandemic. I am also pleased and proud to say that later next year the "Break the Silence" print portfolio will be seen here in my native Scotland through Duncan of Jordonstone Art School, of the University of Dundee. Having Dundee as a location for the exhibition, has another vitally important role, because Dundee, in conjunction with the Welcome Trust, have recently built a new science block and are initiating new micro biological research into the HIV virus. I am not a scientist, so I cannot say exactly how this research will be undertaken. However, I would urge all of those Pambazuka readers who are specialist science trained, and are wishing to pursue research in the field, that they look up the University of Dundee on the internet and contact the science department of that excellent University, and ask what background the science faculty is looking for to join in the proposed research programme. Meanwhile, all those readers who are in the vicinity of Durban and Cape Town, please do look in to the "Break the Silence" exhibition, and with the Pambuka editor's permission, I shall keep all readers informed of the various countries and locations to which the exhibition travels.
* Alex Flett, Kirkcudbright, Scotland
Tagged under GovernanceAn embarrassed government was yesterday forced to postpone a decision on the sale of a £28m military air traffic control system to Tanzania when it emerged at a highly charged meeting of senior ministers that the hardware has already been built at a UK factory after reassurances from the Ministry of Defence that the deal would be nodded through.
Tagged under Governance TanzaniaOver the past few months, the media has been saturated with one or another version of a cultural theory of politics. From a simple Huntingtonian version of a ‘clash of civilizations,’ we now read more refined notions of a clash inside civilizations: specifically, we are told that ‘bad Muslims’ have hijacked Islam which ‘good Muslims’ must now prepare to defend. The implication is that the only way forward is a civil war inside a quarantined Islam.
I want to suggest that we turn the cultural theory of politics on its head. Instead of dismissing history and politics as does culture talk, I suggest we place cultural debates in historical and political contexts. My claim is simple: terrorism is not a cultural residue in modern politics; rather, terrorism is a modern construction.
Iqbal Ahmed writes of a television image from 1985, of Ronald Reagan meeting a group of turbaned men, all Afghani, all leaders of the Mujaheddin. After the meeting, Reagan brought them out into the White House lawn, and introduced them to the media in these words: “These gentlemen are the moral equivalents of America’s founding fathers.”
This was the moment when official America tried to harness one version of Islam in a struggle against the Soviet Union. Before exploring the politics of it, let me clarify the historical moment.
1975 was the year of American defeat in Indochina. 1975 was also the year the Portuguese empire collapsed in Africa. It was the year the center of gravity of the Cold War shifted from Southeast Asia to Southern Africa. The question was: who would pick up the pieces of the Portuguese empire, the US or the Soviet Union?
As the center of gravity of the Cold War shifted, from Southeast Asia to Southern Africa, there was also a shift in US strategy. The Nixon Doctrine [that] had been forged towards the closing years of the Vietnam War but could not be implemented at that late stage – the doctrine that “Asian boys must fight Asian wars” – was really put into practice in Southern Africa. In practice, it translated into a US decision to harness, or even to cultivate, terrorism in the struggle against regimes it considered pro-Soviet. In Southern Africa, the immediate result was a partnership between the US and apartheid South Africa, accused by the UN of perpetrating “a crime against humanity.” Reagan termed this new partnership “constructive engagement.”
South Africa became both conduit and partner of the US in the hot war against those governments in the region considered pro-Soviet. This partnership bolstered a number of terrorist movements: Renamo in Mozambique, and Unita in Angola. Their terrorism was of a type Africa had never seen before. It was not simply that they were willing to tolerate a higher level of civilian casualties in military confrontations – what official America nowadays calls collateral damage. The new thing was that these terrorist movements specifically targeted civilians. It sought specifically to kill and maim civilians, but not all of them. Always, the idea was to leave a few to go and tell the story, to spread fear. The object of spreading fear was to paralyze government.
In another decade, the center of gravity of the Cold War shifted to Central America, to Nicaragua and El Salvador. And so did the center of gravity of US-sponsored terrorism. The Contras were not only tolerated and shielded by official America; they were actively nurtured and directly assisted, as in the mining of harbors.
The shifting center of gravity of the Cold War was the major context in which Afghanistan policy was framed. But it was not the only context. The minor context was the Iranian Revolution of 1979. Ayatullah Khomeini anointed official America as the “Great Satan,” and official Islam as “American Islam.” But instead of also addressing the issues – the sources of resentment against official America – the Reagan administration hoped to create a pro-American Islamic lobby.
The grand plan of the Reagan administration was two-pronged. First, it drooled at the prospect of uniting a billion Muslims around a holy war, a Crusade, against the evil empire. I use the word Crusade, not Jihad, because only the notion of Crusade can accurately convey the frame of mind in which this initiative was taken. Second, the Reagan administration hoped to turn a religious schism inside Islam, between minority Shia and majority Sunni, into a political schism. Thereby, it hoped to contain the influence of the Iranian Revolution as a minority Shia affair.
This is the context in which an American/Saudi/Pakistani alliance was forged, and religious madresas turned into political schools for training cadres. The Islamic world had not seen an armed Jihad for centuries. But now the CIA was determined to create one. It was determined to put a version of tradition at the service of politics. We are told that the CIA looked for a Saudi Prince to lead this Crusade. It could not find a Prince. But it settled for the next best, the son of an illustrious family closely connected to the royal family. This was not a backwater family steeped in pre-modernity, but a cosmopolitan family. The Bin Laden family is a patron of scholarship. It endows programs at universities like Harvard and Yale.
The CIA created the Mujaheddin and Bin Laden as alternatives to secular nationalism. Just as, in another context, the Israeli intelligence created Hamas as an alternative to the secular PLO.
Contemporary “fundamentalism” is a modern project, not a traditional leftover. When the Soviet Union was defeated in Afghanistan, this terror was unleashed on Afghanistan in the name of liberation. As different factions fought over the liberated country – the Northern Alliance against the Taliban – they shelled and destroyed their own cities with artillery.
[After the Cold War and right up to September 10 of this year, the US and Britain compelled African countries to reconcile with terrorist movements. The demand was that governments must share power with terrorist organizations in the name of reconciliation – as in Mozambique, in Sierra Leone, and in Angola.
If terrorism was an official American Cold War brew, it was turned into a local Sierra Leonean or Angolan or Mozambican or Afghani brew after the Cold War. Whose responsibility is it? Like Afghanistan, are these countries hosting terrorism, or are they also hostage to terrorism? I think both.]
The Question of Responsibility
To understand the question of who bears responsibility for the present situation, it will help to contrast two situations, that after the Second World War and that after the Cold War, and compare how the question of responsibility was understood and addressed in two different contexts.
In spite of Pearl Harbor, World War Two was fought in Europe and Asia, not in the US. It is Europe, and not the US, which faced physical and civic destruction at the end of the war. The question of responsibility for postwar reconstruction did not just arise as a moral question; it arose as a political question. Its urgency was underlined by the changing political situation in Yugoslavia, Albania, and particularly, Greece. This is the context in which the US accepted responsibility for restoring conditions for decent life in noncommunist Europe. That initiative was called the Marshal Plan.
The Cold War was not fought in Europe, but in Southeast Asia, in Southern Africa, and in Central America. Should we, ordinary humanity, hold official America responsible for its actions during the Cold War? Should official America be held responsible for napalm bombing and spraying Agent Orange in Vietnam? Should it be held responsible for cultivating terrorist movements in Southern Africa and Central Africa?
Perhaps no other society paid a higher price for the defeat of the Soviet Union than did Afghanistan. Out of a population of roughly 15 million, a million died, another million and a half were maimed, and another five million became refugees. Afghanistan was a brutalized society even before the present war began.
Official America has a habit of not taking responsibility for its own actions. Instead, it habitually looks for a high moral pretext for inaction. I was in Durban at the World Congress Against Racism (WCAR) when the US walked out of it. The Durban conference was about major crimes of the past, about racism, and xenophobia, and related crimes. I returned from Durban to listen to Condeleeza Rice talk about the need to forget slavery because, she said, the pursuit of civilized life requires that we forget the past.
It is true that, unless we learn to forget, life will turn into revenge-seeking. Each of us will have nothing but a catalogue of wrongs done to a long line of ancestors. But civilization cannot be built on just forgetting. We must not only learn to forget, we must also not forget to learn. We must also memorialize, particularly monumental crimes. America was built on two monumental crimes: the genocide of the Native American and the enslavement of the African American. The tendency of official America is to memorialize other peoples’ crimes and to forget its own – to seek a high moral ground as a pretext to ignore real issues.
It is a human tendency to look for others in times of adversity. We seek friends and allies in times of danger. But in times of prosperity, the short-sighted tend to walk away from others. This is why prosperity, and not adversity, is the real litmus test of how we define community. The contemporary history of Southern Africa, Central America, and Afghanistan testifies to this tendency.
Modernity in politics is about moving from exclusion to inclusion, from repression to incorporation. By including those previously excluded, we give those previously alienated a stake in things. By doing so, we broaden the bounds of lived community, and of lived humanity. That perhaps is the real challenge today. It is the recognition that the good life cannot be lived in isolation.
* Mahmood Mamdani, Herbert Lehman Professor of Government and Anthropology, Director, Institute of African Studies, Columbia University
Tagged under Governance"I have no objection to issuing a new anti money laundering law in the crimes of planting, manufacturing and trading in narcotics, nor in the kidnapping and detention of people, nor in terrorism and the importing of and trading in weapons and ammunition, nor in the crimes of libertinism and prostitution, nor those against antiquities or related to the preservation of the environment, to the end of the crimes listed in Article 2 of the draft law on money laundering that was prepared by the government and presented to the People's Assembly for an immediate endorsement. I have no objection to that, but my objection is that the USA is pressuring us to issue that law, and imposes it on us and on other countries against the will of the government and the state agencies and institutions."
Tagged under Governance EgyptThe Second Committee of the United Nations General Assembly concluded its work this week by approving a draft resolution on the World Summit on Sustainable Development. This resolution is expected to be approved by the General Assembly without changes when it takes up the report of the Second Committee on Friday, 21 December 2001. This resolution changes the dates of the WSSD to 26 August - 4 September 2002, advancing the conference dates by one week.
Tagged under GovernanceDefence Minister Mosiuoa Lekota on Sunday launched a bare-knuckled attack on United Democratic Movement leader Bantu Holomisa for suggesting that President Thabo Mbeki had been involved in underhand activities surrounding the multi-billion rand arms deal.
Tagged under Governance South AfricaThe steering committee of Côte d’Ivoire’s National Reconciliation Forum has submitted to President Laurent Gbagbo the results of a three-month public debate in which representatives of political, religious, non-governmental, academic and other groups analysed and proposed solutions for the country's socio-political problems.
Tagged under Governance Cote d’IvoireZambians are scheduled to cast their votes on 27 December in general elections that will mark the end of a decade in power for President Frederick Chiluba. It will be the third time since single-party rule ended in 1991 that the country goes to the polls.
Tagged under Governance ZambiaThe UN General Assembly on Friday adopted a resolution on strengthening the coordination of emergency humanitarian assistance in Sudan, despite Canadian and European Union concerns about inadequacies in its wording and scope.
Tagged under GovernanceIt is well-documented that the Gap (and its family of stores, including Banana Republic and Old Navy), Tommy Hilfiger, Nordstrom, May Co., Sears, Wal-Mart, and most of the big names in US clothing and retail use slave labor. Because they farm out clothing manufacturing to factories all over the world to increase their profit margins, it is impossible for them to insure their workers' basic rights.
Tagged under GovernanceA commissioner at the Anti-corruption, Mrs. Neneh Daboh has described the indigenous business sector as painfully weak and disjointed.
Tagged under GovernanceThe cloud of controversy hanging over the new Electoral Law thickened further as some members of House of Representatives filed an objection for an amendment to the law because of what they described as "a smuggled clause."
Tagged under Governance NigeriaThe World Bank has said that it had launched criminal investigations in the US against it's former task manager for the Kenya Urban Transport Infrastructure Project (Kutip) over allegations of corruption.
Tagged under Governance KenyaThe newly inaugurated National Advisory Committee of the Ghana Accountability Improves Trust is to facilitate government's responsiveness to citizens at the local level and promote accountability and transparency in district assemblies.
Tagged under Governance GhanaThe trial of former Chief of Army Staff, Lt.-Gen. Ishaya Bamaiyi and four others over allegation of attempts to murder The Guardian Publisher, Chief Alex Ibru yesterday further took a dramatic turn as Bamaiyi restated the bribery charge against the trial judge, Justice Ade Alabi accused of the same offence last week by Major Hamza Al-Mustapha, Chief Security Officer (CSO) to the late head of state, General Sani Abacha.
Tagged under Governance NigeriaThe agreement to begin WTO negotiations on investment should serve as a call to action for NGOs, socially responsible business leaders, and others who seek to promote the global public interest. Now more than ever, it is time to mount a proactive advocacy effort based on a positive vision of what constitutes "sustainable and ethical" investment rules.
Tagged under GovernanceThe World Summit for Social Development adopted a human rights framework as part of its strategy to eradicate poverty. The observance of human rights facilitates peaceful co-existence and consequently social and political stability. A democratic society is predicated on respect for human rights. This much is generally recognized. Somewhat more controversial is the third proposition underlying the Social Summit strategy—that a society that wants to achieve social justice also has to implement social and economic rights. There is a powerful school of thought that argues that social justice is the outcome of the market economic system, and not a contrivance of the state.
Tagged under Governance
Pagination
- Previous page
- Page 785
- Next page