I must commend you on your website and am sorry I have only found it now.
Tagged under GovernanceI am currently working on a hyper-textual project concerning the African Charter of Human and Peoples Rights, and the Arab Charter of Human Rights. The main aim of this project is to analyses, compare & contrast, and explain the basic tenants of both Charters from an international law, and human rights perspective. The uniqueness of this project lies within the new IT software that is being used, which has been designed by our IT department at the Mediterranean Academy of Diplomatic Studies ( Diplo Project). this software enables the user to add links, make annotations, and create briefcases in an interactive forum.
Furthermore, the initial research on the African Charter has been completed, and we are ready to move into the next phase, which basically will rely on the contribution of international lawyers, students of human rights, and all those interested in the application of human rights from an African perspective.
Therefore, I am extending an open invitation to all interested in this project to participate in this new research methodology. On my part i will provide you with the software, and of course user names and passwords enabling you to access the information, and contribute online to enriching this innovative method of research.
Please do not hesitate to contact me if you are interested in this project or seek further information.
Furthermore, please do visit the website we have created.Tagged under GovernanceNGOs and trade unions charge that the IMF and World Bank are still imposing strict conditions on loans to borrowing countries. The Reality of Aid 2002, produced by a global coalition of NGOs, states that: "far from abandoning aid conditionality, international financial institutions and bilateral donors are collaborating in an unprecedented consensus to retool the aid regime under the rubric of 'ownership' and aid effectiveness".
Tagged under GovernanceThe United Nations announced on Tuesday that it was
suspending all activities in the Somali capital, Mogadishu, with effect from
Tuesday 9 May, a press release issued the same day by the office of UN
Resident Humanitarian Coordinator stated. According to the statement the action was taken after kidnappers refused to release an abducted UN staff member.Tagged under Governance SomaliaSierra Leoneans await the establishment of a Special Court and a Truth and Reconciliation Commission…. Nigeria pursues domestic trials as the Oputa "Truth Panel" ends its public hearings… Gacaca trials begin in Rwanda… the Congolese negotiations in South Africa put a truth and reconciliation commission on their agenda…. South Africans continue to debate the legacies of their own Truth and Reconciliation Commission… Zimbabwean activists working for a post-Mugabe dispensation consider possible truth, justice and reconciliation options... a host of NGO and CBO-led initiatives at the community level gather momentum in a number of African countries…
Over the past decade, strategies for conflict resolution or democratic transition in Africa have increasingly addressed complex issues of truth, justice and reconciliation. It has become more difficult simply to ignore questions about accountability for serious human rights abuses and reparations and support for the victims. This is welcome, of course. But all apparent breakthroughs bring with them new dangers. In recent years we have become particularly concerned by two distinct but interrelated dangers.
First, there is the danger of off-the-peg solutions that do not take account specific historical and political-economic contexts. Second, there is the danger that those most directly affected -- the victims themselves -- are marginalised or manipulated by initiatives on truth, justice and reconciliation.
In what follows, we offer a brief explanation of our concerns. We then outline an idea for combatting these dangers. This is the creation of a service-providers' network of African NGO's, CBO's and individuals with experience of truth, justice and reconciliation issues. We need your feedback about this idea.
The danger of off-the-peg solutions
African governments and civil society activists who are committed to ending violent conflict or authoritarian rule often look for international assistance in addressing issues of truth, justice and reconciliation. In principle, there is no problem with this. After all, African governments and civil society often lack detailed information about how these issues have been tackled elsewhere. They may also feel that the expertise for such complex, ambitious undertakings is not available locally. Also, African governments and civil society do not generally have the funds to run institutions or processes of accountability and reparation without international assistance.
But this can leave African countries extremely vulnerable to outsiders -- for example, the United Nations, or the plethora of international NGO's now active in this area -- who try to shape these processes according to their own preconceptions. Control over information, expertise and money is a powerful combination. This dependence also leaves African governments and civil society vulnerable to being caught between the potentially conflicting priorities of outsiders - for example, between those who privilege judicial action and those who have a bias towards truth processes; or between the different approaches of lawyers and mental health workers.
In addition, our experience suggests that the outside actors do not always have the expertise that they claim. They often lack the capacity to monitor and evaluate comparative developments or to develop a coherent historical and political analysis of the country in which they have become engaged. Combined with the inevitable bureaucratic inertia, this means that such organisations tend to depend upon prior "policy packages", which they are often reluctant to change radically even if they are inappropriate. One such problematic area in this regard has been the import of inappropriate psycho-therapeutic based models of "trauma healing".
The danger that victims' voices are marginalised
Accountability, reparation and support for victims are, of course, officially at the heart of all truth, justice and reconciliation initiatives in African countries today. But often the victims themselves have not been consulted and have had little participation in the design and implementation of these initiatives. Participation and consultation often amounts to no more than ratifying decisions that have already been taken elsewhere. Consultation should mean a genuinely free debate about the various possible courses of action. Yet there is usually a reluctance to have such a dialogue over a prolonged period and involving all levels of society.
Those African NGO's and CBO's that do have expertise in independent or community-level initiatives on truth, justice and reconciliation are also not always adequately consulted and involved in those processes of design and implementation. This is why accountability institutions and processes often try to control or substitute for grassroots initiatives. This partly explains too why official institutions with a specific life-span such as trials or truth commissions are often ineffective as catalysts for the longer-term follow-up at all levels of society that is needed in African countries emerging from violent conflict or authoritarian rule.
A service-providers' network?
So might an African service-providers' network play a useful role in addressing the twin dangers of "off-the-peg solutions" and the marginalisation of victims' voices? Could such a network be the basis for mutual advocacy and solidarity around issues of "good practice"? African NGO's are already linking up on this issue. For example, the Sierra Leone Working Group on the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, is a coalition of Sierra Leonean NGO's and CBO's established to strengthen Sierra Leonean input into truth and reconciliation processes in that country. In 2001, it sent a delegation to the Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation in South Africa and the Amani Trust in Matabeleland, Zimbabwe, to learn about their community-based truth, justice and reconciliation work. But so far such exchanges have often been on an ad hoc basis. Progress towards more systematic networking appears to have been made in southern Africa, however, where the Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation is coordinating a sub-regionwide research project in partnership with a range of NGO's in the other countries of the sub-region.
There is no reason why such a network could not also draw upon the comparative experience of NGO's and CBO's in other regions. For example, the Amani Trust in Matabeleland, Zimbabwe, has worked with local communities in Matabeleland to exhume victims of human rights abuses there during the Gukurahundi in the mid-1980s and facilitate their dignified reburial. In doing so, it has worked closely with the Argentinian Forensic Anthropology Team, which is also due to be involved in Sierra Leone over the coming years, and developed relationships with human rights organisations in other Latin American countries working in this area.
We are acutely aware that networks can be difficult to sustain and often promise much more than they deliver. Given that this is the case, it might make sense to proceed slowly and to identify one or two areas for concrete cooperation over an initial period of two years. It might be inappropriate for such a network to take any formal institutional shape itself during that initial period. The hub of such a network could be a core group of no more than five African NGO's or CBO's, with one of them taking on initial responsibility for coordination.
But the "first principle "question is whether a service-providers' network of this kind would be desirable. The time, quite simply, may still not be right. Only if its desirability is established do questions of feasibility arise. We remain genuinely undecided. Whether you are involved actively in truth, justice and reconciliation issues in your home country or are simply an interested reader, please do let us know your opinion by replying to us via Pambazuka News.
[The authors are human rights activists who have been involved with a range of truth, justice and reconciliation initiatives in southern and West Africa. They are writing in their personal capacities]
Tagged under GovernanceAS THE United Nations Special Session on Children gets underway, East African countries are admitting they have made little or no progress in meeting the goals for child and maternal health set at a UN conference 12 years ago.
Tagged under GovernanceAfrican intellectuals are divided on the legitimacy of the New Partnership for Africa's Development (Nepad). During a three-day "African Forum for Envisioning Africa by African Scholars" in Nairobi last week, a section of civil society representatives and scholars said that Nepad lacked legitimacy as it was agreed upon by African presidents and sold to Western economic powers for funding without consulting citizens, parliaments and the civil society.
Tagged under GovernanceTANZANIA HAS rejected its ranking by Transparency International as one of the most corrupt countries in the world and described the anti graft body as "an enemy of developing countries." Mr Wilson Masilingi, the Minister in the President's Office responsible for good governance told The EastAfrican last Friday: "The criteria used to reach such conclusions is biased against nations like Tanzania which are struggling against poverty."
Tagged under Governance TanzaniaJust a year ago, U.S. Secretary of State Colin Powell was lauding Mali's 10-year-old democracy as "a model for the rest of the world to see and focus on." Amid a chaotic and disputed presidential vote count this month, however, many were left fearing that Mali — West Africa's model — had become only the latest promising young African democracy to slide back into old, corrupt ways.
Tagged under GovernanceThe Transparency International Bribe Payers Index 2002, carried out by Gallup International Association (GIA), will be launched in Paris, Hong Kong and Johannesburg on 14 May 2002. The BPI 2002 ranks the propensity to bribe of firms and business sectors from 21 exporting countries on the basis of an exclusive survey by GIA in 15 emerging market economies.
Tagged under GovernanceA recent report by Transparency International UK estimates that the official arms trade accounts for 50% of all corrupt international transactions. A conservative estimate of the level of commissions paid is 10%, in an industry worth $40bn a year.
Tagged under GovernanceAfrica is losing as much as US$4 billion a year through top professionals seeking better jobs abroad, according to research by a senior economist at Addis Ababa University.
Tagged under GovernanceIn 2002, with its population of close to 22 million people, Uganda is pivotal to the success of the much-publicized reform of the World Bank and International Monetary Fund policies. These international financial institutions and indeed the Government of Uganda and civil society organizations have lauded the Ugandan experience as an international flagship for participatory governance, transparency and economic growth over the last two years. Based on secondary materials and interviews with leading officials within the Government of Uganda, bi-lateral and multi-lateral institutions and civil society organizations in Uganda and Washington DC over 2001, this study presents evidence that crucial policy prescriptions within the PRSC and PRGF may impair Uganda's ability to effectively realize its antipoverty and growth goals.
Tagged under GovernanceEconomic success in Africa does not have a chance unless governments provide the necessary funds to combat the rampant HIV/AIDS pandemic on the continent, renowned economist Jeffrey Sachs told the U.N. Economic and Social Council. Sachs is also U.N. Secretary General Kofi Annan's special adviser on development issues.
Tagged under GovernanceThe UN Security Council has proposed setting up a panel of experts to investigate violations of the arms embargo on Somalia. In a resolution, adopted on Friday, it called on the Secretary-General to set up a two-member team that would prepare a plan of action detailing the necessary resources and expertise for such a panel.
Tagged under Governance SomaliaThe Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights this has continued its consideration of an initial report from Benin on how that country was implementing the provisions of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. In response to questions raised by Committee Experts on Thursday afternoon, the members of Benin's delegation said that the Government was convinced that the process of decentralization would allow the population, through elections, to increase its responsibilities at the local level.
Tagged under Governance BeninTHE Congress of South African Trade Unions is concerned that political apathy is eroding its power and influence. Secretary-general Zwelinzima Vavi told the Sunday Times this week that Cosatu leaders were shocked by the poor attendance of workers at May Day celebrations. He said discussions had taken place on how to make it more relevant to its members.
Tagged under Governance South AfricaZamfara government has dismissed 11 traditional rulers, four sharia court judges and five civil servants on the recommendation of the state Anti-corruption Commission since its inception three years ago. The Chairman of the Commission, Alhaji Aliyu Mohammed, who made the disclosure to newsmen in Gusau, the state capital, said the dismissed officers were found guilty of corrupt practices as a result of complaints and petitions against them from members of the public.
Tagged under Governance NigeriaThe mountain areas of Africa are scattered throughout the continent and occupy approximately 2,960,997 Km2. Mountain areas of Africa have a high diversity in terms of ecological conditions, resource use, physical constraints to resource use, socio-economic characteristics of resources users, biodiversity and biodiversity and scenic beauty. The immediate challenge for sustainable development of mountain areas “is how can we slow the process, reverse the trend and move towards sustainable development in mountain areas”. This paper highlights the environmental and socio-economic importance of mountain areas, the constraints and opportunities and the way forward.
Tagged under GovernanceOpposed by meek pro-democracy forces, King Mswati's government is likely to succeed in promulgating a new constitution to preserve palace power, Swazi political analysts told IRIN. "Mswati seems like small potatoes compared to Robert Mugabe and other national leader cutthroats," said a Manzini businessman. "No one has ever died in political violence here, and there aren't even any demonstrations anymore. Why should the world bother with little Swaziland?"
Tagged under Governance Swaziland
Pagination
- Previous page
- Page 765
- Next page