Commissioner Faith Pansy Tlakula, member of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights with special responsibility for freedom of expression talks to Hakima Abbas about how the African rights system works and the challenges it faces.
Hakima Abbas (HA): Please could you provide us with a brief overview of the situation of freedom of expression in Africa.
Faith Pansy Tlakula (FPT): It’s difficult to give an overview of the situation in Africa as a whole. As I have pointed out several times since my appointment, the standards exist in principle and freedom of expression is indeed protected in Africa by different instruments. So, as far as the adoption of instruments is concerned, there doesn’t seem to be an issue. However, in practice, freedom of expression is not yet a reality for many people on the continent so the issue is implementing the existing principles. While the media in Africa has begun to act as a cornerstone of democracy and source of balanced information in some states, there is clearly still place for improvement in the right to freedom of expression.
In my reports to the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (the commission, hereafter), I have repeatedly expressed my concerns over reports of alleged violations of the right to freedom of expression in a number of African states and I am constantly receiving a considerable number of such reports.
These allegations included, but were not limited to:
• Harassment, threats and intimidation of journalists and media practitioners, undue political interference with the media, victimisation of media houses deemed critical of government policies, seizure of publications and destruction of equipment, and closure of private media establishments
• The adoption of repressive laws or amendments to existing legislation that limit freedom of expression and the free flow of information
• Reports of disappearances, arbitrary arrests and detention of journalists and media practitioners, who in some cases are held incommunicado and for extended periods of time without charges or due process of law
• The murder of journalists with impunity, torture and other forms of ill-treatment and death in custody of journalists and media practitioners.HA: What mechanisms are in place in Africa to guarantee freedom of expression?
FPT: The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights was established in 1987 by virtue of Article 30 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights (the charter, hereafter) with the specific mandate to promote human and peoples’ rights and ensure their protection in Africa. The promotional mandate of the commission involves education and sensitisation with a view to creating a culture of respect for human rights on the continent. The protective mandate of the commission entails essentially the receipt and consideration of complaints alleging human rights violations. In addition to these two main mandates, the commission is also empowered to interpret the charter at the request of a state party, the African Union (AU), or an institution recognised by the AU.
Under Article 9, the charter guarantees every individual the right to receive information and express and disseminate their opinions within the law. Although this right is considered as a cornerstone of development, its protection under the charter could be said to have been severely watered down by the clawback clause inserted within the same article. Indeed, while the first paragraph provides for an unlimited right for every individual to receive information, the right of every individual to express and disseminate their opinions within the law, as provided for in paragraph 2, may be interpreted by some states in a manner that unreasonably limits it.
Aware of the importance of upholding respect for the right to freedom of expression to the nurturing of democracy, human rights and sustainable development, and faced with many violations of the right to freedom of expression, the commission has, throughout the years, adopted various measures to strengthen the promotion and protection of this right.
One of the first initiatives taken by the commission was through pronouncements and recommendations made in the context of individual communications. Indeed, the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights has, through its communication procedure and the broad interpretation powers it enjoys under the charter, developed jurisprudence on human and peoples’ rights in general, and the right to freedom of expression in particular.
The commission has also dealt with issues of freedom of expression in Africa through resolutions and declarations and by promoting dialogue with member states when states’ reports are being considered, or when commissioners make promotional and fact-finding missions to member states.
Moreover, at its 32nd ordinary session held in Banjul, Gambia in October 2002, the commission adopted, by resolution, the Declaration on Principles of Freedom of Expression in Africa. The declaration sets out important benchmarks and elaborates on the precise meaning and scope of the guarantees of freedom of expression laid down under Article 9 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights.
In view of the situation of the right to freedom of expression in Africa, the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights initially appointed a Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression in Africa in December 2004. I was appointed as mandate-holder in December 2005.
The state of freedom of expression on the African continent prompted the commission to adopt a resolution in November 2006. Expressing its concerns over the current situation, the commission called on member states to:
take all necessary measures in order to uphold their obligations under the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and other international instruments, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights providing for the right to freedom of expression
but also to:
extend their full collaboration with the mandate of the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression in Africa, in order to strengthen the right to freedom of expression on the African continent and work towards the effective implementation of the principles enshrined in the Declaration of Principles on Freedom of Expression in Africa and other applicable human rights standards in the region in order to achieve this goal.
Finally, in order to ensure effective implementation of the charter, the AU established the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights (the court) under the Protocol to the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights establishing an African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights (the protocol). The protocol was adopted in June 1998 and entered into force in January 2004. Twenty-three states have ratified the protocol so far and the court is now operational. The court will act in an adjudicatory and advisory capacity. According to the preamble and Articles 2 and 8 of the protocol, the court complements the protection mandate of the commission under Article 45 (2) of the charter. Unlike the commission, the court’s decisions are binding and final and not subject to appeal.
Under Article 3 of the protocol:1. The jurisdiction of the Court shall extend to all cases and disputes submitted to it concerning the interpretation and application of the Charter, this Protocol and any other relevant Human Rights instrument ratified by the States concerned.
2. In the event of a dispute as to whether the Court has jurisdiction, the Court shall decide.
The court can therefore enforce other human rights treaties ratified by African states.
The protocol also allows the court to issue advisory opinions, in accordance with Article 4, which provides that:1. At the request of a Member State of the OAU, the OAU, any of its organs, or any African organisation recognised by the OAU, the Court may provide an opinion on any legal matter relating to the Charter or any other relevant human rights instruments, provided that the subject matter of the opinion is not related to a matter being examined by the Commission.
2. The Court shall give reasons for its advisory opinions provided that every judge shall be entitled to deliver a separate or dissenting decision.Besides, the court may also ‘try to reach an amicable settlement in a case pending before it in accordance with the provisions of the Charter’.
HA: What are the challenges of guaranteeing respect for freedom of expression in Africa?
FPT: Obviously, there are many challenges but they also differ from country to country. In some cases, it could be lack of understanding of the principles, and in others, a total disregard for them, which shows the importance of adopting a country-specific approach to this issue.
As I mentioned earlier, African states are obliged to uphold the existing principles of freedom of expression. They have to ensure respect for the rights recognised by the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and to support the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights in its work to guarantee the implementation of the charter. Moreover, Principle XVI of the Declaration of Principles on Freedom of Expression in Africa clearly provides that: ‘States Parties to the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights should make every effort to give practical effect to these principles’.
One should not be too pessimistic, however, as the progress and achievements made over the last few decades deserve neither to be underestimated nor forgotten. These achievements, which include the adoption of the Declaration of Principles on Freedom of Expression in Africa and the appointment of a Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression, simply need to be seen as the ground on which we now have to build an African continent characterised by free media and the free flow of information.
HA: What is your role and mandate as Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression?
FPT: In a nutshell, my role as special rapporteur is to monitor freedom of expression in Africa and report to the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights accordingly. My role includes monitoring violations of the right to freedom of expression on the continent, recommending to the commission measures to address the violations and assisting AU member states to review their national media laws and policies to comply with the principles set out in the declaration. Part of my mandate is also to take action on behalf of alleged victims of violations of the right to freedom of expression, including by sending appeals to member states, asking them for clarifications on reports forwarded to me by different reliable sources.
In addition to, and in conformity with, the relevant resolutions of the commission, my work reflects the provisions of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights, the Declaration of Principles on Freedom of Expression in Africa as well as other relevant international and regional human rights instruments including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (especially Article 19), the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (especially Article 19), as well as other treaties, resolutions, conventions and declarations relating to the right to freedom of opinion and expression.
According to the resolution on the mandate and the appointment of a special rapporteur on freedom of expression in Africa, my mandate includes:
• Analysing national media legislation, policies and practice within member states, monitoring their compliance with freedom of expression standards in general and the Declaration of Principles on Freedom of Expression in particular, and advising member states accordingly
• Undertaking investigative missions to member states where reports of massive violations of the right to freedom of expression are made and making appropriate recommendations to the commission
• Undertaking country missions and any other promotional activity that would strengthen the full enjoyment of the right to freedom of expression in Africa
• Making public interventions where violations of the right to freedom of expression have been brought to the rapporteur’s attention. This could be in the form of issuing public statements, press releases, or urgent appeals;
• Keeping a proper record of violations of the right to freedom of expression and publishing this in reports submitted to the commission
• Submitting reports at each ordinary session of the commission on the status of the enjoyment of the right to freedom of expression in Africa.In the conduct of this mandate, it is possible and, I believe, highly desirable for me to hold meetings with government officials to make recommendations about applying accepted standards of freedom of expression. This advisory role is crucial to the success of this mandate; I hope member states will gradually come to see it as a useful tool in helping them to comply with their obligations under international human rights law.
HA: What is the relationship between the special rapporteur and the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights?
FPT: It is a very close relationship. Indeed, unlike United Nations special rapporteurs, for instance, who are independent experts, the special rapporteurs are members of the commission, actual commissioners, who are appointed to a specific mandate. This means that I am not only the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression in Africa but I am also one of the 11 members who form the commission.
Besides, in view of the fact that we work part-time as commissioners, the bulk of the work is entrusted to the secretariat of the commission. The secretariat, for instance, will assist in the preparation of missions, drafting of mission reports and speeches, undertake research, hold organising workshops and seminars, raise funds for activities, etc. At the moment, there is one legal officer at the secretariat who is specifically assigned to my mandate.
HA: What impact have your role as special rapporteur, and the work of the African Commission on Human and People’s Rights more broadly, had on human rights for the people of Africa?
FPT: The work of the commission has had an impact in several ways as you can see from my responses to the previous questions. For instance, under its promotional mandate, the commission raises awareness about the existing human rights standards and can assist in elaborating on these standards. For instance, as far as the right to freedom of expression is concerned, I could mention the adoption of the Declaration of Principles of Freedom of Expression, which elaborates on Article 9 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights. The declaration is indeed a good example of the impact of the work of the commission in general and of the mandate of the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression in Africa in particular, which has been key in the elaboration of the declaration.
HA: Some might say that, given the continued human rights violations that plague the continent, the African human rights system including the commission is a failure. Would you agree?
FPT: Of course, I would disagree that the system is a failure. Obviously, huge challenges remain, but we also have to look at the achievements, even if these sometimes appear very limited compared to the challenges. Realistically, the situation on the continent will not change overnight but we have to be optimistic and use our strengths and build on our achievements to move forward instead of thinking about our past mistakes – some might say failures – unless we are looking back only to learn from these past experiences.
HA: What do you see as the challenges and strengths of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights?FPT: I think that we all know about the challenges, including limited resources (financial and personnel), which create a lot of other difficulties. However, since we are celebrating the 20th anniversary, I would like to focus on the strengths of the commission, which include its ‘accessibility’. The commission is the forum where NGOs, individuals and other alleged victims of human rights violations can have their voices heard. It is also the place where a true dialogue can be initiated between member states and alleged victims or organisations that want to bring a situation to the attention of the public at large. It is noteworthy that since the last ordinary session, the number of NGOs enjoying observer status with the commission has reached 367 and that the number of national human rights institutions with affiliate status has also grown over the years.
HA: In November 2007, the African Commission on Human and People’s Rights will be celebrating its 20th year of existence. What do you feel has been the greatest accomplishment of the commission?
FPT: Increased sensitisation and recognition of the work done by the commission by different stakeholders. To have existed for 20 years is an achievement indeed, but at the same time, 20 years is a rather short period for an institution with a mandate as wide and far-reaching as that of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights, given all the challenges it has to face. We must look at what has been achieved so far, take stock and fix ourselves realistic objectives for the future.
HA: Moving forward what do you think would strengthen the work and impact of the ACHPR?
FPT: I have mentioned the increased recognition of the work done by the commission, but there is a need for the commission to reach a wider, grassroots audience. I believe that the better the mandate and work of the commission are understood by everyone on the continent, and abroad, the greater the legitimacy of the commission and consequently the more collaboration it will receive from AU member states. We need to build more bridges.
HA: How can civil society and citizens in Africa help to ensure freedom of expression on the continent?
FPT: There is an obvious need for civil society, NGOs and other actors including me as Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression in Africa, to keep raising awareness of the principles of freedom of expression in Africa, to campaign for the implementation of the relevant instruments and to call on governments to respect their obligations under international human rights law by bringing their laws in line with international standards. Civil society and the citizens of Africa can also help in collaborating with my mandate by, for instance, continuing to send in information on alleged violations of the rights.
Only collaboration between all the actors involved, including, obviously, the full participation of the states, can ultimately lead to full respect of the right to freedom of expression on the African continent, and so the real co-existence of nations based on the principles of democracy. Indeed, together we can help states implement these principles by adopting a culturally sensitive approach, taking into account the different situations prevailing in each country and region of the continent. That is where the importance of raising awareness becomes truly relevant and where the work of a mandate such as mine draws all its significance.
* Hakima Abbas is the AU Policy analyst for Fahamu Networks for Social Justice
* Please send comments to or comment online at www.pambazuka.org
Tagged under GovernanceThe International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) has called on the government of Senegal to put an end to "oppression" of journalists after the arrest of an editor this morning. This is the fourth arrest of a reporter or editor in the last month for allegedly offending the President or endangering national security. El Malick Seck, editor of the news website Rewmi.com was arrested this morning at the headquarters of his company in the city of Thiès by the Division of Criminal Investigation (DIC) who is holding him in Dakar.
Tagged under Artificial Intelligence & Technologies SenegalAs part of its Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), British Airways is to invest 100, 000 pounds (Sh13.5 million) to assist four rural schools of Kenya to establish Information Technology centres. The four 'slum' schools are in Nairobi's Mukuru area. In an interview, the head of Community Relations at BA, Ms Mary Barry said that Kenyan 'slum' schools were at the heart of the airline and that the IT support could not have come at a better time.
Tagged under Artificial Intelligence & Technologies KenyaProtesters took to the streets of Chad's capital N'Djamena on Thursday to demand that seven Europeans freed at the weekend return to face trial over an attempt to fly 103 African children to live in Europe. Some held placards criticising French President Nicolas Sarkozy, who flew in to pick up three French journalists and four Spanish air stewardesses on Sunday and has vowed to come back for another 10 Europeans facing child abduction charges.
Tagged under Violence & Peace ChadThe Spanish king's planned visit to Ceuta and Melilla has prompted Morocco to recall its ambassador to Spain over what it called a "regrettable" move. King Mohammed VI immediately recalled the ambassador on Friday, after the Spanish government formally announced that King Juan Carlos would visit the territories on Monday. Morocco considers Ceuta and Mellila Moroccan territories and has demanded Spain end its "occupation". The territories have been under Spanish control since the 15th and 17th centuries. Spain has refused to enter into any negotiations with Morocco about the two cities.
Tagged under Land & EnvironmentFor several years Port Elizabeth hosted hundreds of refugees without apparent difficulty; refugees largely went about their business, creating self-sustaining employment and living productive lives. They seemed to have integrated well, without the support that the UN refugee agency and its partners have provided to refugees in Johannesburg, Pretoria, Durban and Cape Town.
Tagged under Violence & Peace South AfricaAn unexpected challenge has been directed at the economic partnership agreement (EPA) being negotiated between the European Union and the east and southern African group. Two lobby groups have filed a law suit in Kenya to halt the signing of the EPA. The Kenyan government, on the other hand, has defended its position, saying that the trade deal is in the best interest of all concerned.
Tagged under Violence & Peace KenyaAfrican migrants in the UK are among the most vulnerable to HIV infection, accounting for the greatest number of new diagnoses in recent years according to a new report by Panos. Being HIV positive can intensify experiences of stigma and marginalisation, apparent in inadequate living conditions, limited employment opportunities, and lack of visibility in policy decisions. Stigmatising media coverage of African migrants can exacerbate the feelings of isolation and frequently prevents people from coming forward to access health services.
Tagged under Food, Health & WellbeingThe resignation of First Deputy President Martin Nduwimana should help break a crippling political impasse and expedite peace talks in Burundi, according to an opposition leader. Nduwimana resigned on 7 November, saying he wanted to give the country's institutions a chance to resume work. “I handed my resignation to the head of state who accepted it,” Nduwimana said. “I don’t want to be an obstacle to peace.”
Tagged under Governance BurundiThe Centre for Human Rights, University of Pretoria, together with the ILO and the African Commission’s Working Group on Indigenous Communities/Populations in Africa, are carrying out a research project on the promotion of indigenous peoples’ rights through the implementation of ILO Convention No. 169 and the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights. We are seeking persons with good research and writing skills and extensive experience in the rights of indigenous communities within particular African countries, to undertake desk top reviews of a number of countries in Africa. Deadine: 19 November 2007
Tagged under Global South & Transnational StrugglesThe Inter Region Economic Network (IREN) is organizing a Pan Africa Workshop on Service Delivery to Small Holder Farmers (Feb 4 – 6, 2007). IREN is inviting farmers, industry players, media, academia and health experts from Africa to discuss how best the continent can exit dependency and be prosperous through commercializing agricultural ideas.
Africa's coastal infrastructure faces increasing danger of erosion from rising sea levels caused by climate change, the head of the U.N. Environment Programme said on Thursday. Achim Steiner, executive director of UNEP, told a news conference that port facilities, refineries and expensive private properties were already degrading as a result of global warming.
Tagged under GovernanceAiming to facilitate efforts to achieve a lasting solution to the crisis in the strife-torn North Kivu province of the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), a senior United Nations official has held meeting with local authorities there. Assistant Secretary-General for Political Affairs Haile Menkerios, who was sent by Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon on the special mission last week, began his meetings in Kinshasa on Saturday, according to the UN Mission in the DRC (MONUC).
Tagged under Governance Democratic Republic of CongoA government funded human rights watchdog said Wednesday it wants an international panel of security experts to investigate extra-judicial killings in the last few months after the police commissioner rubbished their report which implicates them. Nearly 500 people have been killed between June and October and their bodies dumped in mortuaries in the city and its suburbs according to a Kenya National Commission on Human Rights report released this week.
Tagged under Violence & Peace KenyaThe expulsion of the top U.N. humanitarian official from South Darfur will hinder efforts to provide aid to some 1 million aid-dependent Darfuris by removing a key member of the aid team, officials said on Thursday. Wael al-Haj Ibrahim was the 11th aid worker expelled from Sudan this year and the second Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) staff member expelled from South Darfur state in six months.
Tagged under Global South & Transnational StrugglesShuro-Net is a Somaliland Human rights network comprising 38 separate organisations including women's groups, human rights defenders, youth groups etc.
Tagged under Violence & Peace Mali“Young Men at Risk: Transforming the Power of a Generation” seeks to collect groundbreaking approaches to addressing these challenges and to sponsor informed debate and comment on work being done to help young men thrive. The competition will award funding for the most innovative work in fields from music to mental health to support the expansion of their impact on a generation of young men. Entry is between now and January 23, 2008.
Tagged under ResourcesIn certain parts of Africa, female genital mutilation (FGM) has been linked to religion, with Muslim communities mistakenly believing that the practice is a religious requirement. But in Côte d'Ivoire, religion is also being put at the service of fighting FGM. El Hadj Kassoum Traoré, an imam at a small mosque in Belleville -- one of the poorer areas in the commercial hub of Abidjan -- sets aside time during the Friday prayer for explaining the dangers of FGM to worshippers. The weekly prayer is an obligation for able Muslim men.
Tagged under Gender & Social JusticeZambian first Lady Maureen Mwanawasa is encouraging women to demand safer sex from their partners, not negotiate for it. Ms Mwanawasa recently made the statement at the launch of the FC2 female condom campaign at the Lusaka City Market, handing out condoms to the public. "Negotiating for safer sex is a term that has become accepted world wide, yet, it puts a woman at the mercy of a man," Ms Mwanawasa told the Lusaka market crowd. "I do not believe that a woman should negotiate for safer sex, but demand safer sex."
Tagged under Gender & Social Justice ZambiaThe impact of HIV/AIDS in southern Africa, which has nine of the world's most affected countries, needs to be reassessed as a "humanitarian emergency" on its own, enabling interventions to be made timeously, a leading AIDS researcher argues in a new paper. For this to happen, Alan Whiteside, director of the Health Economics and HIV/AIDS Research Division of the University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, said in the paper, co-authored by researcher Amy Whalley, the conventional understanding of a humanitarian emergency has to be rethought.
Tagged under Violence & Peace Swaziland
Pagination
- Previous page
- Page 993
- Next page