No one's talking about SA's Great Depression
The transformation of the South African economy from a protected and
subsidised environment to one fully exposed to the vagaries of the market
has hit South African workers hard, a new report says. A massive increase in productivity by workers during the same period has not
only gone unrewarded but has contributed to an unemployment crisis.
No one's talking about SA's Great Depression
April 22 2002 at 06:33AM
By Leon Engelbrecht
The transformation of the South African economy from a protected and
subsidised environment to one fully exposed to the vagaries of the market
has hit South African workers hard, a new report says.
A massive increase in productivity by workers during the same period has not
only gone unrewarded but has contributed to an unemployment crisis.
The report, written by Tradek economist Mike Schussler, found the
transformation was accompanied by job losses "that has rarely happened
anywhere else in the world."
'This means that more than one in five jobs has been lost over the last 12
years'
During the apartheid era the South African economy was dominated by
subsidies and tax breaks to achieve goals such as "resettling" people in the
"homelands", or propping up farmers, then a major National Party
constituency.
"Subsidies as a percentage of GDP were less than Europe today but distorted
the economy nonetheless," Schussler said.
The report found that since 1989 more than 19,2 percent of all formal sector
jobs outside of agriculture have been lost.
"This means that more than one in five jobs has been lost over the last 12
years in the private sector in South Africa," the report said.
"The odd thing about this adjustment is that not many people are saying
anything about it," Schussler commented.
'The 40 percent without breadwinners are increasing at the fastest rate in
the world'
Added to this is a pervasive - and mistaken - view that the labour market is
inflexible and it is difficult to retrench people.
Unemployment according to the latest Labour Force survey stood at 29,5
percent in September 2001 which was 3,1 percent higher than in February
2001.
Longer-term comparisons were difficult as the unemployment figures had been
collected in different ways in the last two decades.
Nevertheless, data from the early 1980s indicated that unemployment in South
Africa was only about 10 percent of the workforce.
During the Great Depression unemployment in America peaked at 24.9 percent
in March 1933. Unemployment stayed above the 20-percent level for five years
during that period.
Here, unemployment has been above the 20-percent level since the
mid-nineties and is unlikely to drop below that over the next few years.
"That means even if South Africa did create more than a million jobs in the
next five years our unemployment rate would not only have peaked at above
the level of the US during the Great Depression but would have stayed there
for at least twice as long as the American unemployment rate did, Schussler
pointed out.
"Yet South Africa is doing very little to combat the problem apart from the
occassional announcement of more cash for some or other committee dealing
with unemployment."
Once allocated, the money is seldom spent. The Umsobomvo Fund, which has
more than R1 billion in the bank, has not spent anything at all, he charged.
"As a result, many who want to work are actually giving up the will to look
for employment."
At the same time, Schussler said, workers have done much to boost the
economy.
"Labour productivity has increased with an average of 2,3 percent a year
over the last 20 years which is one of the highest rates outside of Asia."
Only China, Sri Lanka, Taiwan and Korea are still rated as more productive
than South Africa by the International Labour Organisation.
"In historical terms there have been few countries that have seen such huge
productivity gains for such a long time and (this) is a good indication that
the South African economy can look ahead for better times to come,"
Schussler said.
The Tradek economist also found that South African manufacturing labour
costs had declined radically over the last two decades both in actual
dollar-per-hour terms and in relation to other countries' relative costs.
"Perhaps the most dramatic cost reductions have been in relation to the
newly-industrialised Asian countries, namely Taiwan, Korea, Hong Kong and
Singapore. In 1980 South African manufacturing labour costs were 260 percent
that of the average Asian emerging economy," he said.
The estimate for last year is that South Africa's labour cost per hour was
only half that of the Asian countries in question and, in fact, was also
cheaper than almost all emerging markets - except Mexico - according to a
survey by the US's Bureau of Labour Statistics.
"Compared to Europe and America, South African hourly labour rates have also
declined quickly to about half the level that they were in 1980. Not only
that but with the rapid improvement of productivity rates South African
labour must now count amongst the cheapest in the world," Schussler said.
Local labour rates were about 30 percent the level of those in Europe and
America, but are now around 15 percent the level of those in Europe and
America.
"Furthermore, South African hourly labour costs in dollars have seen the
biggest fall of any country in the 29-country survey. South African labour
costs have decline by around 40 percent since 1995. This in itself is a very
big adjustment and gives clearer evidence of an extremely flexible labour
market."
Turning to the plight of the poor, Schussler said the major divide between
South Africans was no longer between races, but between the employed and the
unemployed.
"Those with jobs have had increases well above the rate of inflation and
grow richer - relatively speaking - every year," he said.
"Those who do not have work, grow poorer, while the cost of making ends meet
rises every month. The rich are the 21 percent of the population that has
work and of course their families. They represent about 60 percent of the
total population when they are combined with their dependants. The 40
percent without breadwinners are the new poor and they are increasing at the
fastest rate in the world," he warned. - Sapa
---------------------------------------
Most of the stories featured here are also available at
http://www.labourstart.org/southafrica/.
Inclusion of news items does not necessarily imply endorsement of the
views expressed.
---------------------------------------
An injury to one is an injury to all!
---------------------------------------
Visit http://www.union.org.za to get a free full-function online e-mail
address
---------------------------------------
News mailing list
News@cosatu.org.za
http://gate.cosatu.org.za/mailman/listinfo/news