Re: PAMBAZUKA NEWS 62
The "Declaration on Africa's Development Challenges" created by "CODESRIA"
and "TWN-Africa" is painfully reminiscent of some of the corporate memos I used to receive during my time in a large NGO. When you read phrases like, "the primacy of the question and paradigm of national and regional development on the agenda of social discourse and intellectual engagement and advocacy" it's time to turn on Muppet Show reruns to find more serious intellectual stimulation.
Making Africa the prosperous continent it should be requires freeing African people with democracy and human rights, it means freeing African economies through free trade, free markets, and individual economic empowerment. And it requires freeing Africans from fear of oppression, both external AND (more commonly) internal. The anti-market policies advocated in the CODESRIA/TWN-Africa declaration are typical of some of the most counterproductive, destructive policies that have brought so many African countries to their knees in the past four decades.
Despite what the CODESRIA/TWN-Africa declaration would have us think, the key to making Africa into the economic powerhouse it should rightfully be is NOT oil, social/gender equality, or magic wands. The key is understanding one important principle: There is no such thing as "African economics." There is "economics," period.
Value, money, loans, interest, self-interest, greed, generosity, rational choice etc. work the same in Africa as they do in Peru or Iowa or Fiji or anywhere in the world. Economics are value neutral, but ignoring economics does cause poverty. This is reality. And the more we ignore reality, the more we distort reality in the interests of political and social agendas, the more it will cost us in the long run. Ignoring economic realities has already cost Africa 40 years of development. If we read the CODESRIA/TWN-Africa declaration it is clear they are ready to waste 40 more in the ridiculous search for their utopia.
Regarding the editorial in PAMBAZUKA NEWS 62 (distributed 3 May 2002):
The "Declaration on Africa's Development Challenges" created by "CODESRIA"
and "TWN-Africa" is painfully reminiscent of some of the corporate memos I used to receive during my time in a large NGO. When you read phrases like, "the primacy of the question and paradigm of national and regional development on the agenda of social discourse and intellectual engagement and advocacy" it's time to turn on Muppet Show reruns to find more serious intellectual stimulation.
Making Africa the prosperous continent it should be requires freeing African people with democracy and human rights, it means freeing African economies through free trade, free markets, and individual economic empowerment. And it requires freeing Africans from fear of oppression, both external AND (more commonly) internal. The anti-market policies advocated in the CODESRIA/TWN-Africa declaration are typical of some of the most counterproductive, destructive policies that have brought so many African countries to their knees in the past four decades.
Despite what the CODESRIA/TWN-Africa declaration would have us think, the key to making Africa into the economic powerhouse it should rightfully be is NOT oil, social/gender equality, or magic wands. The key is understanding one important principle: There is no such thing as "African economics." There is "economics," period.
Value, money, loans, interest, self-interest, greed, generosity, rational choice etc. work the same in Africa as they do in Peru or Iowa or Fiji or anywhere in the world. Economics are value neutral, but ignoring economics does cause poverty. This is reality. And the more we ignore reality, the more we distort reality in the interests of political and social agendas, the more it will cost us in the long run. Ignoring economic realities has already cost Africa 40 years of development. If we read the CODESRIA/TWN-Africa declaration it is clear they are ready to waste 40 more in the ridiculous search for their utopia.
The essential goals of IMF/WB conditions are for African countries to live within their means. That means balanced budgets, affordable governments and rational social and economic policies. And the primary reason there is so much debt is because these conditions are all too often ignored.
The absolutely worst form of neocolonialism is shockingly voluntary: when African governments borrow to support their own unsustainable economic systems. By owing money to Western banks African governments are surrendering control. Nevertheless, international financial institutions have been generous in forgiving debt when African governments have made rational economic decisions and allowed greater economic decision-making to their citizens, moved towards democratic, transparent and accountable governments, and accepted the critical need for basic human rights for ALL people. (I believe the CODESRIA/TWN-Africa declaration did mention the need for better governments in there somewhere, so they didn't miss everything.)
Unfortunately there are no magic wands that change the reality of economics.
So what should we be doing to make Africa more prosperous?
1. Make the dream of an African Economic Union come true, with NO economic barriers, free unfettered trade continent-wide, a single currency, and a unified voice that can work for greater trade freedom at international economic forums. Trade is not a zero-sum game, trade creates jobs and wealth
- everyone wins. This African economic union should be done in five years, not twenty (or fifty as some academics advocate!)
2. Demand the opening of Western markets to Africa - especially agricultural markets. Nothing the West has done has caused more damage than their hypocritical agricultural policies, which subsidize and protect their rich farmers (costing their consumers billions!) while slamming the door in the face of Africa's cheaper agricultural exports. Africa should automatically reciprocate free trade offers from anywhere in the world to stimulate as much trade as possible.
3. ALLOW Africans to improve themselves - governments don't produce food or products - citizens do. Allow Africans to freely produce what they want for the market without orders from the government. Africans ain't idiots -
allow African consumers to make their own choices about what products they wish to purchase, be they domestic or foreign.
4. Attract Foreign Direct Investment by making African markets more attractive. Cut regulations and red tape thus reducing opportunities for market-crippling corruption. Make political discourse and democratic change constructive and peaceful. The new African Union will only be taken seriously by Africans and the World if it requires members to have truly democratic governments, and members should be prepared to publicly condemn oppressive African governments and leaders.
5. Finally, take advantage of Africa's untapped human capital. African entrepreneurs are the best - they learned to survive in some of the most repressive political and economic systems the world has ever seen. They thrive in free markets as evidenced by the millions of successful African immigrants working in Europe and the United States. Why not allow them to thrive at home? Africa should be capitalizing on its human talent, not exporting it.
Although Africa has suffered far more than its share of colonialism, war, natural disasters and disease, nothing has killed more Africans than poverty.
And nothing has caused more poverty than the idiotic anti-market policies of the past 40 years. Unfortunately, the CODESRIA/TWN-Africa declaration ain't calling for improving economic policies, it is calling for more of the same .
. .
Africa has a great future and hopefully the economic and political failures of the past forty years will soon be just a bad memory. For some African countries they have nowhere to go but up, for others it is not too late to turn things around before they hit rock bottom. Once the economics are sorted out, and once African governments learn to have faith in African people, then there is no force in the world that can prevent Africans from attaining their rightful place among the world's prosperous people.
Regards, Doug Brooks (202) 297-9717 (Washington, DC)
Hoosier84@aol.com