john garrison, world bank global development gateway
We are writing to address some of the issues raised by the Bretton Woods Project in its April 2001 brief on the Development Gateway entitled "A Tower of Babel on the Internet? The World Bank's Development Gateway" which was circulated widely in several electronic discussions and lists.
First of all, it is important to state that we welcome these latest comments on the Gateway from Bretton Woods Project and other organizations, as this promotes useful and constructive debate on the Development Gateway and on the use of information and communications technology more broadly. The internet is still largely uncharted space requiring a good deal of exchange and analysis by a wide variety of people in order to understand its pitfalls and more fully grasp its potential.
Below are comments on the most important points raised by Bretton Woods Project in their brief. For a more comprehensive discussion of the policies and features of the Development Gateway Portal and the Development Gateway Foundation, please refer to the FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) document located in the "About Us" section of the Gateway.
Ongoing contact with Bretton Woods Project
The Gateway team has had ongoing contact with the Bretton Woods Project staff,
with our latest meeting in March, and we consider this exchange useful. While we
don't agree with some of the concerns and interpretations drawn by Bretton Woods
Project, we do find some of the analysis concerning the difficulties of building
and managing a global portal thoughtful. The issues of managing content while
striving to both ensure quality and plurality or how to successfully publish in
many languages simultaneously, are challenges which all portals of this nature
face, including those operated by civil society organizations (CSOs). These and
other challenges are certainly debated constantly within the Gateway team, and
we welcome the input and lessons learned from others who are also working on IT
for development. We are pleased to note that Bretton Woods Project posted their
brief on the Development Gateway site itself (on the global NGO Page), and hope
that it will generate some discussion there as well.
Providing Visibility to Southern Voices
The Development Gateway is not only committed to addressing the growing digital
divide, but many of its innovative design features are precisely geared to
providing visibility to Southern development experiences and voices. The Gateway
team is actively pursuing collaboration with CSOs in developing countries to
manage content, and has already established partnerships with such organizations
as TARAhaat and Fondo Indígena. It is also supporting civil society ICT
initiatives such as the sub-site by the NGO Working Group of the World Bank in
the Eastern/Central Europe Region and the independent NGO portal in Latin
America being established by ALOP. Further, its open-source and XML-based
software allow users across the world to post resources, retrieve data, and
participate in online discussions. Finally, the Country Gateways, which are
being established in Latin America, Africa, and Asia, will promote local
information sharing and ICT capacity-building in developing countries. These 32
Country Gateways are being established by consortia composed of dozens of local
organizations from the academic, private sector, and civil society, and
governmental sectors. (see the "Contributors" page in the "About Us" section of
the Gateway for a complete list of organizations)
Dominating the Internet?
The Development Gateway does not see itself as the one "super-site" on
development issues, but rather an additional platform among the numerous
existing portals geared to sustainable development. What makes the Gateway
unique is its commitment to bringing diverse sectors (government, civil society,
private sector) together, and its network of country-based portals, which will
allow for more fluid interaction between local, regional, and global levels. The
notion that the Gateway could in some way dominate or control development
information on the Internet ? even if this were its intention, which it is not
-- simply does not stand up to the origins and decentralized nature of the
medium. Further, the Gateway will not compete with existing development portals
or siphon off funds now being destined for civil society Internet efforts. The
Development Gateway Foundation, when established in the later half of 2001, will
leverage new funding for the ICT field, including providing small-grant funding
to civil society in collaboration with infoDev. In short, the Development
Gateway will only be deemed successful if it can enhance inter-connectivity
among existing Internet portals/networks and leverage greater resources for
government, civil society, and donor agency ICT initiatives.
Experimental Nature of the Gateway
Reflecting the experimental nature of the Internet, the Gateway initiative has
been characterized by a "learning by doing" approach, which is analyzing
different architecture models, experimenting with different software
applications, testing different content management approaches, and piloting
several institutional partnership approaches. Throughout the process we have
spoken to a diverse range of interlocutors and learned from the experience of
other similar ICT initiatives, including from the extensive civil society
experience in this field. Unlike what is portrayed by the Bretton Woods Project
brief, decisions about the Gateway design and governance structure are not "set
in stone", and new approaches will continue to be explored and changes made as
the project moves forward. Indeed, many significant changes have already been
adopted as a result of the feedback we have received (see below).
Responding to Feedback
The Gateway has actively sought feedback from a broad range of stakeholders in
government, civil society, and the private sector. During 2000 the team held
over a dozen meetings with leading CSO networks in North America, Europe, and
Latin America, and held several electronic discussions such as the 7-week
discussion hosted by GKD. The Gateway has responded to the feedback received --
both positive and negative -- by being open and frank, and by constantly
reviewing the concept and design in light of comments and suggestions. The
Gateway's key documents (business plan, concept note, consultation meeting
notes), implementation timetable, and names of our partner organizations are
posted on our site (see "About Us" section). Further, as a response to this
feedback the Gateway team has adopted a series of needed changes into its
technology, editorial policy, and governance structure. These include evolving
to a more decentralized architecture and testing of autonomous sub-sites; moving
from an individual to an institutional model of guided pages; appointing an
external Editorial Advisory Committee; and establishing a multi-stakeholder
Gateway Foundation.
Decentralized Content Management Through Partnerships
The Gateway is piloting several models of decentralized content management on
its topic pages. Initially it began with an individual topic guide approach, but
in order to ensure greater diversity and attract greater institutional
collaboration, the Gateway has increasingly been partnering with organizations
from civil society and the donor community. These organizations select advisors
for their pages, manage the content posted on their site, and select which
resources to highlight. Such partner organizations have also assisted the
Gateway in determining the taxonomy of topic and sub-topic pages as this has
evolved over time, in order to capture crosscutting themes such as gender and
ensure a more holistic view of development. This decentralized content
management approach brings a good measure of diversity and ensures that
recognized practitioners in the development field set the quality standards.
In conclusion, there is no doubt that launching and maintaining a portal such as
the Gateway is a challenge. But we feel that while it is ambitious, it is not
beyond reach, and could be a valuable tool in the fight against poverty. The
issues of technological design, editorial policy, taxonomy definition, content
management, and governance structure are complex and require a thoughtful and
collaborative approach. For this reason, the Gateway team has consulted openly
and widely with civil society, government, and the private sector, and has made
available major background and policy documents. The Gateway is a work in
progress and the feedback received has been instrumental in assessing underlying
notions, introducing needed design changes, and fine-tuning specific features.
The active participation of CSOs representing different constituencies and
issues, particularly from the developing world, will help the Gateway to reach
its full potential. We thus invite civil society organizations to work with us
on the Gateway initiative by registering on the site, searching data,
contributing content, participating in electronic discussions, monitoring the
Gateway, sending us feedback, serving as topic guides and advisors, and
collaborating on pilot ICT initiatives.
For additional information on these issues and how the Gateway is working with
civil society please visit our site or (http://www.developmentgateway.org/) or
contact John Garrison at: [email]jgarrison@worldbank.org
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
John Garrison
Civil Society Specialist
Development Gateway
1776 G St. N.W. Room G2-024
Washington DC 20433
PHONE: (202) 473-4742 / FAX: (202) 522-7479
EMAIL: [email]jgarrison@worldbank.org
WEB: