• Contributor | Governance

    An ActionAid Policy Brief

    News of the famine in Malawi (like elsewhere in the world) developed as rural whispers slowly, too slowly finding their way to the ears of urban policymakers in Lilongwe and foreign capitals from October 2001. The Malawi Economic Justice Network (MEJN) and the Catholic Commission for Justice and Peace had attempted unsuccessfully to mobilize activist groups to pressurize the Government to declare a “famine”. The data provided then by these organizations and others was dismissed as lacking credibility.

    0n February 22nd 2002, MEJN released a press statement calling for Government and donor action and stating “The Government should acknowledge that there is hunger in Malawi; make the holding of maize a crime, subsidize the price of maize in Malawi; government and civil society should provide food supplies to vulnerable groups”. At this point, the mainstream international media started broadcasting reports of a famine emergency, desperation and critical food shortages.

    By June 2002, the disaster had claimed up to a thousand African lives. Yet, in Washington DC, media coverage and policy treatment of the disaster has been confusing. Media coverage of the discourse between the Government of Malawi, bi-lateral donors or the International Monetary headlined alternately corruption abounded or criminal macroeconomic policy. Situated within this discourse and resourced by the public release of a comprehensive report by ActionAidMalawi this policy brief isolates one important factor for examination and public scrutiny namely, the failure of macro-economic and structural policy to safeguard against the famine in Malawi.

    We remain conscious of the myriad of complex variables, both causal and correlative, often associated with famine situations. As with all famines, the causes fall into two categories: ‘trigger factors’ (livelihood shocks and response failures), and ‘underlying causes’ (factors that create vulnerability to livelihood shocks). As elaborated in the ActionAidMalawi report (June 2002), the disaster can be explained as the product of a combination of both ‘technical’ issues and political challenges. Issues of poor early warning systems, market failures, structural poverty and inadequate infrastructure are also parts of this crisis.

    However unlike previous famines in Malawi, this one was preceded by over a decade of structural and agriculturally related policy reforms by successive Malawian Governments advised by the International Monetary Fund. While not ignoring the many domestic factors contained in the ActionAidMalawi report, this report singles out key international policy components for attention.

    MAJOR FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

    The ActionAid Malawi report clarifies the broad array of causes for the famine.1998/99 and 1999/00 were two good production years. However, localised floods reduced the 2000/01 maize harvest and left a shortfall estimated at 237,000 metric tones in 2000-2001. In 2001-2002 the shortfall had almost tripled rising to 600,000 metric tones. Initial crop estimates suggested that the maize deficit would be partly offset by a 30% increase in roots and tubers production (especially cassava) over the previous year. This figure was wrong and generated misplaced complacency. Donors failed to react to signals of an impending food crisis, the Strategic Grain Reserve was sold, and senior members of government denied the existence of a famine until February 2002, when civil society and the media presented irrefutable evidence of hunger-related deaths.

    The decision to sell the Strategic Grain Reserve (SGR) followed advice from the IMF to reduce the level of buffer stocks held from 165,000 MT to 60,000 MT. Instead, almost all of the reserve was sold, much of it on local markets, against IMF advice to export it in order to minimise disincentives to maize producers.

    There is some evidence that much of the SGR was sold to local traders, who stockpiled it and profiteered from hunger. When the government attempted to cover the resulting food gap through imports, this proved extremely expensive, and a series of logistical problems caused fatal delays and an escalation of maize prices to unaffordable levels. Concern about various governance issues – including suspicions of corrupt practice around the SGR sale – caused donors to vacillate for several months before responding to signals of distress with food assistance.

    Following stakeholder consultations across the Malawian Government, civil society and donor communities on a draft version of the report, ActionAid further calls on the International Monetary Fund to act quickly to institute the following measures;

    1. A temporary moratorium on further structural reforms to formulate, set and meet the food security objectives of a national development strategy in conjunction with the Malawian Government, civil society and donors.

    2. Review and propose legal and operational measures that support the Malawian Government to regulate various forms of manipulation, rent-seeking and un-competitive activities by sector agents.

    3. Institute a tracking study that traces which sectors and interests have benefited from the dissolution of the Strategic Grain reserve and the reduction of institutional and structural regulatory and supervisory capacity. This is in line with the commitment to undertake Poverty and Social Impact Assessments.

    Tagged under Governance Malawi

  • Contributor | Governance

    An ActionAid Report Commissioned by ActionAid Malawi, Written by Stephen Devereux, June 2002
    The food crisis in Malawi in early 2002 resulted in several hundred hunger-related deaths
    – perhaps several thousand. These deaths make this the worst famine in living memory,
    certainly worse than the drought of 1991/92, and worse even than the Nyasaland famine
    of 1949. This paper attempts to explain why the famine occurred, and draws lessons for policy interventions to prevent future famines.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    Africa's social, economic, and political relations urgently need to be transformed through a focused and determined international effort if Africa is to be lifted out of the poverty trap. The New Partnership for Africa's Development (NEPAD) presents itself as a visionary and dynamic initiative by a core group of new generation African leaders to reconstruct and develop the continent. But NEPAD's vision is blurred by fixing its sights on increased global integration and rapid private sector growth as the answer to overcoming poverty, and by its failure to engage with Africa's people to transform the continent. The remarkable political will generated by NEPAD must be focused into a participatory transformation of Africa through direct, immediate, and decisive action to overcome the causes of Africa's impoverishment.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    World Bank officials had repeatedly tried to bribe Tanzanian ministers during the construction of roads under the Integrated Roads Programme (IRP), a Dar es Salaam court has been told.

    Tagged under Governance Tanzania

  • Contributor | Governance

    Corruption has cost Africa at least US $140 billion, Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo revealed on Thursday. He said his country alone had spent millions of dollars trying to recover money illegally spirited away by corrupt former leaders. "Imagine what that can do for Africa today," he told a conference in the Ethiopian capital, Addis Ababa. "That is a lot of money."

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    A boost for Mozambique came on Monday when Sweden pledged US $14 million for rural agricultural development over the next three years, AFP reported.

    Tagged under Governance Mozambique

  • Contributor | Governance

    The World Bank has approved loans totaling US $237 million for Nigeria to improve its health sector and reduce poverty in urban areas.

    Tagged under Governance Nigeria

  • Contributor | Governance

    How has AIDS affected development in the world's poorest regions? How can we reduce the devastation caused by the epidemic? The Zimbabwe-based NGO, SAfAIDS, examined the impact of HIV in southern Africa where the disease affects a quarter of the adult population.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    The Public Service Commission has expressed doubt about the viability of setting up a single anticorruption agency in SA. In a review of the country's various anti-corruption agencies, tabled in Parliament, the commission said priority should be given to retaining the existing agencies while making them more effective through better co-ordination.

    Tagged under Governance South Africa

  • Contributor | Governance

    The Organisation of African Unity (OAU) and representatives from African civil society were set to begin a series of meetings in Addis Ababa on Tuesday, aimed at laying the groundwork for the African Union (AU) which will replace the OAU next month. The objective of the conference, the second of its kind, is "to reinforce the interface between African civil society and the African Union", a statement issued by the OAU said.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    Cyril Allen has been suspended as chairman of the ruling National Patriotic Party (NPP) following claims about corruption in government involving the misappropriation of funds by officials.

    Tagged under Governance Liberia

  • Contributor | Governance

    In an unprecedented show of unity, African leaders this week launched a broadside against market protection in the world's wealthiest nations. "We are not asking for alms," was their message. "Open your markets and we will help ourselves."

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    Given that there has not been any democratic debate and given that NEPAD contains serious threats to our people, we call on the Mauritian government not to go ahead with the presentation of NEPAD in the coming G8 meeting and its launch in July 2002.

    Tagged under Governance Mauritius

  • Contributor | Governance

    The Cambridge City Council – where World Bank president James Wolfensohn was due to speak last week at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology – has joined the anti-globalisation movement by voting to boycott the bank’s bonds. Not wasting words about the terms the World Bank imposes on the developing world in exchange for access to development funding, the city government accused the bank of being "the principal architect and enforcer of corporate globalization."

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    The newly established Anti Corruption Courts may meet the same fate as the Kenya Anti-Corruption Authority if an application challenging their constitutionality is allowed in court.

    Tagged under Governance Kenya

  • Contributor | Governance

    No matter what do not privatise your water supply to anyone. Water is second only to oxygen as being essential for life, so don't privatise what is so essential for life! Water belongs to the people and it is the responsibility of government to see that the water remains safe and available for all the people!

    Tagged under Governance

  • I think you are doing a good job.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    Debt has crippled many developing countries. Often based on loans taken out by prior rulers and dictators, many of which various Western nations put into power to suit their interests, millions face poorer and poorer living standards and precious resources are diverted to debt repayment. This page provides detailed background information on the debt crisis facing developing countries.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    This anthology of health communication materials is intended to offer social change communication practitioners and academics a set of materials that have already been used with success in the field and have the recognition of people working in communication and development. It is also designed as a resource for people living with HIV/AIDS in their efforts to develop and sustain grass-roots support and advocacy initiatives for others living with the disease.

    Tagged under Governance

  • Contributor | Governance

    Does Nepad simply represent an extension of neo-colonial globalisation? Forty years ago in his book The Wretched of the Earth, Frantz Fanon warned of partnerships that are forged by an African leadership which identifies "with the decadence of the bourgeoisie of the West. We need not think that it is jumping ahead; it is in fact beginning at the end. It is already senile before it has come to know the petulance, the fearlessness, or the will to succeed of youth." This book reproduces commentary on Nepad from major social movements, trade unions, progressive intellectuals and other community leaders. It includes the original Nepad and a paragraph-by-paragraph annotated critique.

    Tagged under Governance