Debt relief has become a prominent issue in recent discussions about development, poverty and the relationship between developed and developing countries. The debt problems of the poorest countries have attracted the attention of development agencies that fear that the crisis may worsen poverty and economic decline in which the indebted nations are trapped. The inability to serve external debt by the severely indebted low-income poor countries is vividly reflected not only in massive build-up of arrears but most importantly by the number and frequency of rescheduling. Thus the debate on debt relief is no longer confined to economic and financial spheres; it is transcending every human domain - health, education, agriculture and industry.

Many development agencies and skeptics have expressed widespread doubts regarding the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative (HIPC) - launched in 1996 - and its successor the Enhanced Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative's (EHIPC) ability to achieve the promised objective of a “robust exit from the burden of unsustainable debts” for developing countries. Problems associated with the design and implementation of the initiative suggest that neither of the two HIPC versions has succeeded in providing an adequate response to the Third World debt overhang. An analysis of key debt indicators shows that external debt and debt-servicing problems are most severe and persistent in the heavily indebted poor countries (HIPCs), the target group of the HIPC Initiative.

Throughout the process, creditors failed to put sufficient political will, resources and serious analysis into the debt reduction operations. Debt reduction targets were set and reset arbitrarily - writing off 30 percent, then 50 percent, and so on - rather than based on serious assessments of the needs of each country. Despite claims of success by creditors for their Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) initiative for debt reduction, the IMF estimated that Africa's debt service payments would only go as low as 17.1 percent of export earnings in 2001 (down from 20.3 percent in 1999), before rising again to 18.4 percent in 2002. The process has been much slower than expected and the initiative is suffering from problems of under funding, excessive conditionality, and restrictions over eligibility, inadequate debt relief and cumbersome procedures.

The Overall Picture of the Process

There has been disagreement over what constitutes 'sustainable debt' in the HIPC initiative. Sustainability is subject to the determination of export performance and many debt campaigners fear overly optimistic calculations will reduce the amount of debt reduction and may mean that countries fall back into the debt trap.

It seems the International Financial Institutions are only interested in the Third World debt crisis when it reaches proportions that threaten the poor countries' ability to service their debt to Northern creditors. Thus sustainable debt to the Bretton Woods institutions is when a country reaches a level where it can meet its current and future repayment obligations in full. Debt relief has not managed to ease domestic expenditure constraints and the curbing of investments.

The 22 African countries that have so far qualified to receive some relief are still required to pay almost $2 billion each year in debt repayments to wealthy creditor countries and institutions, mainly to the World Bank and IMF themselves. African countries' efforts to address urgent domestic priorities, from poverty reduction to the fight against HIV/AIDS, continue to be undermined by their persistent debt burden. Most African governments still spend up to three times more on debt repayments than on health care for their own people Not only are some countries spending more on debt payments after they receive debt relief, but they are overshooting the World Bank and IMF's own definitions of debt sustainability. Uganda, the first HIPC graduate, currently has debts of over 200% of the debt-to-exports ratio. This will be the third time Uganda has exceeded its debt sustainability after reaching completion points. Surprisingly, the World Bank and IMF have changed definitions of debt sustainability to include liquidity as the operative criterion.

The HIPC initiative is further flawed because it is tied to controversial economic adjustment measures. In his speech to the International Monetary and Financial and Development Committees in Prague on September 24 and 25, 2000, Canadian Finance Minister Paul Martin develops a critique of the current HIPC process, including Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs), especially the overburdening of countries with a huge quantity of conditions to fulfill before receiving debt relief. Martin cites the problem of overburdening the HIPCs with "unrealistic conditionalities", and an excessive concern among creditors with the "quantity of conditionality rather than its quality."

It is interesting to observe that although Nigeria's debt stock is the largest in West Africa and the country is experiencing growing poverty, she has not been recognized as an HIPC eligible country. Debt relief has been more successful in protecting the interests of the creditors than the debtors. It is actually designed and controlled by creditors to extract the maximum possible in debt repayments.

According to the UN Secretary General's report of 2000 there are 18 least developed countries that are not included in the HIPC category, and some of them are considered severely or moderately indebted according to the World Bank classification. For instance, most of the debt-distressed African countries are classified as moderately indebted middle-income countries such as Zimbabwe while Gabon and Nigeria are both severely indebted yet excluded from the HIPC initiative.

The HIPC Initiative obfuscates the illegitimacy of most of Africa's debt. As such, it fundamentally undermines the strong imperative for debt cancellation. It sanctions the continued exploitation of indebted countries by rich creditor nations and institutions. Many of the loans that are being re-paid were made during the Cold War to repressive regimes and corrupt leaders, who used the money to strengthen their rule or to line their own pockets. Many more loans were made without attention to the viability of planned projects or to the capacity of the recipient country to make repayments.

Out of 20 HIPCs that have already reached HIPC decision point, four countries (Mali, Niger, Sierra Leone and Zambia) will have annual debt service payments due in 2003-2005 which will actually be higher than their annual debt services paid in 1998-2000. Five countries will be paying almost as much in debt service payments as before HIPC (Ethiopia, Guinea-Bissau, Honduras, Nicaragua, Uganda). In six countries, a modest $15 million in 2003-2005 will reduce annual debts serviced. Over half of the HIPCs are spending more than 15% of their government revenue on debt servicing.

Despite modest recovery in some countries, poverty has intensified, and human development indicators - life expectancy, infant mortality, and school enrolment have worsened. The export basket remains un-diversified. Since the start of the HIPC process the fragile industrial base has shrunk even further (de-industrialisation) in many countries. In short, HIPCs worsened the crisis on a number of scores. The debt under HIPCs strongly and negatively affects economic growth, threatens the sustainability of reforms, and prevents the development of a capable and functioning state due to the fiscal crisis that it engenders.

Recommendations:

1. The way in which debt relief is calculated for each country needs to be reviewed and alternatives adopted. The reliance on a debt-to-export ratio to calculate debt relief packages, based on World Bank and IMF projections, is flawed.
2. There is a need for an independent panel of experts not unduly influenced by creditor interests to reassess the debt sustainability, eligibility for debt reduction, and the amount of debt reduction needed, conditionality and financing of developing countries.
3. Future reviews of debt sustainability should also bear in mind the impact of debt relief on progress towards the achievement of the development goals contained in the Millennium Declaration.
4. Reform of the international strategy regarding official debt of poor countries should address the problems of debt distressed low-income countries that are not currently eligible for special treatment accorded to the HIPCs.
5. Third World governments should be afforded the chance to determine their own approaches to poverty reduction, in consultation with civil society groups and other partners - not to have these prescribed to them by external powers.
6. Needless to re-iterate, the idea of all countries caught in the debt trap forming a cartel to maximise the effectiveness of an international campaign of debt repudiation has been around for some time.

Conclusion

The analysis above shows that there are serious flaws in the HIPC initiative's approach to the Third World debt crisis. Levels of debt repayment after HIPC initiative are far too high, undermining the necessary investment needed to accelerate poverty reduction. In the absence of radical reform, HIPC will join a long list of failed poverty reduction initiatives. Past and present initiatives at international debt relief are increasingly acknowledged to be inadequate and flawed. The creditors should not monopolise decision-making on debt resolutions and there is a need for the debtor countries to come up with their own initiatives.

The IMF and World Bank are off-track on meeting their performance benchmarks in the HIPC initiative. Any solution to the debt crisis must move beyond debt relief and conditionality, to consider debt within the wider context of equitable and sustainable development. It should address socio-economic and developmental relations between debtor and creditor countries. Needless to state again that if global efforts to reduce poverty and fight underdevelopment are to be successful, Third World debt must be canceled outright.

* Send your comments to

Interest in African oil has been further heightened by the US-led war against Iraq; recent strikes by Venezuelan oil workers; and by potential political instability in Saudi Arabia - all of which underscore America's vulnerability as its voracious appetite for oil grows. Oil development in West Africa offers many attractions, experts say. Reserves are bountiful, the quality is high and shipping routes to America are generally shorter than from other regions.

The head of the UN peacekeeping mission in Ethiopia and Eritrea is holding key talks with South African President Thabo Mbeki on the peace process between the two countries, the UN said on Thursday. The UN’s Mission in Ethiopia and Eritrea (UNMEE) has recently expressed concern over the three-year-old peace process which is now at a critical stage.

The Ghanaian government has successfully prosecuted and convicted two former ministers, a senior civil servant and a foreigner for their roles in a $20 million rice project which left Ghana with a $20 million debt and no rice. The foreigner - in addition to bagging a jail term - was also ordered to refund $20 million.

Inside the hot, stuffy hearing room, already two months into the case of forgotten bank accounts and unexplained fleets of luxury four-wheel drive vehicles, Justice Julie Sebutinde loses her temper - again. She wags her finger at the witnesses, employees of Uganda's notoriously corrupt tax authority. "Today, I am going to have you for lunch and supper," she barks. Ms. Sebutinde, a petite, fiery mother of two, is the Ugandan government's weapon of choice against corruption. Her investigations of the police department, the military, and most recently, the tax authority, have exposed graft that has managed to shock a country where public skimming rarely surprises anyone.

The IFI Watchers Network calendar lists events of interest to organisations worldwide which are monitoring international financial institutions (IFIs) such as the World Bank, the IMF, and regional development banks.

The full 109 liberalisation requests made by the EU to the WTO in June 2002 were previously inaccessible to the public but have just been leaked. It is now possible to find out which countries the EU are targeting and which sectors and assess these intentions against the rhetoric of the EU. The World Development Movement (WDM) conclude from a preliminary analysis of the EU’s leaked requests, targeting 109 countries, two key points:
First, the EU’s claim to be pursuing a ‘development agenda’ is hollow rhetoric. The EU is pursuing an agenda aimed solely at benefiting its multinational companies Second, these requests should be open to public scrutiny. It is simply not acceptable that these documents should be secret and it is unfortunate that the only way the public gets access to this information is through leaks.

The United Nations Observer Mission in Democratic Republic of Congo (MONUC) must urgently protect civilians threatened by renewed violence in the war-torn region of Ituri in northeastern Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Human Rights Watch says. Following the withdrawal of Ugandan troops from the provincial capital of Bunia, Hema militias began fighting Lendu and Ngiti militias for control of the town.

Corruption is the fundamental cause of underdevelopment in Mozambique, according to Assistant Attorney- General Isabel Rupia, who heads the anti-corruption unit in the Attorney-General's Office.

At least nine people, including a senior government official, were killed in violence related to the elections for Nigeria's 36 state legislatures at the weekend, police said on Tuesday.

The follow-up committee for the inter-Congolese dialogue (ICD) has published its calendar for the establishment of various institutions of the two-year national transitional government to be installed in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC).

The European Union Election Observer Mission (EU.EOM) to the recently held general elections in Nigeria has described the coverage of the polls by the Nigerian media as "flawed". In its second preliminary report on the election released on April 22, the EU Observer Mission stated that the media "failed to provide unbiased, fair and informative coverage of the political parties and candidates contesting the elections".

The irregularities reported in this month's Nigerian elections are a mix of elementary and intermediate techniques - deplorable, but all too common around the world. Whether their total effect was enough to call the election a stolen one is a call for statisticians to make. But seen in stark political terms, any judgment of the election has to take into account not just the voting process, but the context - those endless organisational difficulties, not to mention the high cost -and the most vexed question of all: whether the fraud made any real difference to the outcome.

The Catholic Institute for International Relations (CIIR) strongly supports the Lenten pastoral letter of April 2003 of the Zimbabwe Catholic Bishops' Conference (ZCBC) condemning the 'frightening' corruption, lawlessness and abuses of power committed by the Mugabe government in Zimbabwe. The ZCBC accused president Robert Mugabe of failing 'to provide leadership that enables the creation of an environment that enhances truth, justice, love and freedom'.

I take this time to introduce to you our youth group based in the slums of Nairobi, Kenya and known as Kibera slums. For starters, this is one of the largest informal settlements in the world and is mainly inhabited by low income earning people. Within this bigger slum, we saw a need for starting a youth group that shall respond to the needs and concerns of youth given the fact that they had been greatly marginalized.

The tranquil and festive atmosphere in which Somaliland held presidential elections on 14 April has been shattered. On the afternoon of 19 April, the National Electoral Commission (NEC) announced that the Udub candidate, the incumbent president Dahir Kahin Rayaale, had won. His margin of victory was said to be a mere 80 votes and the result was immediately called into question, triggering disturbances in two of the towns where the main opposition party, Kulmiye, had done particularly well—Burao and Gebiley.

I have enjoyed reading your publication. Development should be initiated and supported by people from the grass roots level. Of course, some relevant technical support is required. To me the three pillars of self-reliance are: Community Organisation; Human Resources; and Community financing. Furthermore, donors distribute some services which make the people more dependent, which I call poison. Thanks and Regards.

Eddie Mupeso, the head of Zambia's state broadcaster, has been arrested and charged with abuse of office. Mupeso is the latest in a long line of high profile public figures held in the country's widening anti-corruption crackdown.

It is now mandatory for public officers, including the President and MPs, to declare their wealth. This follows the signing into law of two anti-graft Bills by President Kibaki. They include the Public Officer Ethics Bill, which requires public officers to declare their wealth and that of their spouses, upon taking office.

I appreciate your efforts, keep it up!

Uwem Robert Otu
African Youth Movement on the Environment, Lagos, Nigeria